6 ms·
Everyone in my office runs MS Office for inane reasons, I did try to make them move to openoffice/libreoffice w/ thunderbird, we run an open stack behind the sc
by dijit 13y ago
Everyone in my office runs MS Office for inane reasons, I did try to make them move to openoffice/libreoffice w/ thunderbird, we run an open stack behind the scenes and things simply integrate better..
I feel like this is a massive 'told ya so' after spending thousands of pounds of company money on licenses, now I'll have to spend hours of my time fixing everyones machine one by one, just in case. >_<
hopefully a fix comes in soon and I don't have to worry too much, I assume it will but getting everyone to update (well, forcing it) is a bit hard too.
- spacehome 13y agoSerious question -- I don't intend to troll -- I've heard lots of people claim that as soon as OpenOffice et al. get more popular, more malware will target them. It's not as if Microsoft has a monopoly on bugs. Do you think there's ay truth to this line of thinking?
- danielweber 13y agoFrom a security situation, the worst situation is everyone running different mail clients, because then if any one of them has a vulnerability someone can send in a crafted mail to take over their box and gain access to your private company docs. "Monoculture" isn't always bad.
- niels_olson 13y agoI don't understand this theory that monoculture is safer in a corporate environment. Any interesting organization has more than one secret recipe. Virtually everyone has different access to different systems. If they are all vulnerable to the same bug, the attacker quickly gains control of everything. If they gain control of a single segment, then they can be detected. The odds of the attack being identified once that segment is compromised is much higher, since everyone else has the opportunity to identify the bad behavior.
- mpyne 13y agoI think the theory is that once you have any beachhead onto a system, that existing local priv escalation exploits and network mapping techniques are almost always sufficient to complete the exploitation of your corporate network. So if you have 5 people using 5 different email clients, all 5 of those must be kept secure from spear phishing or email-viewing vulnerabilities to avoid having a hacker get a beachhead on your network. But if those 5 people are using 1 email client, you only have to keep that 1 safe (and you'd have to keep it safe anyways). Monocultures are probably bad for drive-by automated hacking though, so I suppose it's a matter of deciding what threat model you're most at risk from.
- niels_olson 13y ago> you only have to keep that 1 safe This argument may appeal to the self-indulgent system administrator who believes he alone knows perfection. In reality, there is no perfection. One must know there are things one does not know. If China is stock-piling zero days against Outlook, how are you to know? In fact, if there is anything we have learned from biological systems, surely it is that when a monoculture falls, it falls harder and faster than any other variation.
- danielweber 13y agoI know it's appealing, but don't try too hard to apply biological analogies to computers. If you are trying to mitigate against all your computers being taken down at once, diversify. If you are trying to keep intruders out of your network, reduce your surface area.
- mpyne 13y agoWell, let me reiterate: "(and you'd have to keep it safe anyways)". You're right that no one is perfect, but that's no reason to expand the number of directions threats can come from.
- lawnchair_larry 13y agoThis is the opposite of the commonly held belief in security.[1] As an attacker, I would invest all of my efforts into finding a 0day in one application, knowing it would work on any machine I choose. If everyone uses different software, say for browsers, there are 3 or 4 major options and a fully reliable exploit (which is rare, but for the sake of argument) will still fail on 25% of targets. Now I need four 0days to know that I can compromise my target. If you're running multiple OSes, the same vulnerability requires a different exploit, so the number goes up even more. I also need a high quality rootkit that works on all of them. It's not as though I only have to compromise a single box in an entire network to get what I need. Though I don't need to compromise every single box either, so in practice it's somewhere in the middle. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monoculture_%28computer_science%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monoculture_%28computer_science...
- npizzolato 13y agoDo you need 4 0days or 4 targets? I would assume the latter would be the easier thing to get. If that's true, the GPs point has some merit. You just need to find one person running some insecure software and choose him as your target. (I will fully admit I know little about how security works in practice, and would be glad to be proven wrong!)
- rbanffy 13y ago> just need to find one person running some insecure software and choose him as your target. The more options they use, the less likely it is the right person will be running the right exploitable client. You need all vulnerabilities aligned to succeed.
- danielweber 13y agoRight, if I want into your network, I just need in. I don't need to compromise every single person. Now if you were discussing resistance to worms, everyone being different helps. It depends on your threat model.
- lawnchair_larry 13y agoI don't think they'll ever get that popular. Malware still isn't targeting Word and Outlook for Mac, despite them being vulnerable, so OpenOffice has a long way to go.
- barake 13y agoIt looks like the temporary fix is just adding a registry key[1]. This can be automated via login scripts or pushed in a SCCM package. 1: https://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/security/advisory/2953095 https://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/security/advisory/295309...
- MichaelGG 13y agoA quick search reveals arbitrary code vulnerabilities in OpenOffice, too, so what's your point? Large surface area apps written in C++ will probably always have these issues.
- gtirloni 13y agoYou tried to make them move to openoffice/libreoffice w/ thunderbird but apparently you failed. Could you share what was the experience like?
- golergka 13y agoAs someone who used Word, and especially Excel (for data analysis) pretty intensively — if I couldn't use these tools for work, I'd probably think very hard about finding another job. Excel is miles ahead not only of any competing software, even it's OSX version is very subpar to the Windows one: I used parallels just to run it on my Mac. The usability difference is so big, it's like comparing working with and without version control in terms of productivity.
- icantthinkofone 13y agoMost people don't use Word or Excel anywhere near as you do and only use them cause...cause...er...you're supposed to. Aren't you? Like cause everyone uses Photoshop cause...you're supposed to. Aren't you?
- golergka 13y agoNo, I used them because I tried nearly all of the alternatives and decided that they were the best for the task at hand.
- the_ancient 13y agoChances are you are the type of person I complain about every day. Using Excel for things it should not be used for.... There are true data analysis tools on the market, Excel is not one of them
- golergka 13y agoI didn't say that it was the _only_ tool I used. I also regularly used R and SQL. However, it is the best tool for fast mockups and visualization.
- stinos 13y agospend hours of my time fixing everyones machine one by one probably you could instead spend those on writing an automated solution then run it against all machines?