3 ms·
I have not played 1024; but, I will say the mechanic of 2048 is very different from Threes: it would be like saying that Bejeweled is a "clone" of Tetris Attack
by saurik 13y ago
I have not played 1024; but, I will say the mechanic of 2048 is very different from Threes: it would be like saying that Bejeweled is a "clone" of Tetris Attack, that Sonic the Hedgehog is a "clone" of Super Mario Brothers, or that Flappy Bird is a "clone" of Lunar Lander. These games all have many superficial similarities, and even share similar control mechanics, but they are in fact very very different to people playing the games: the strategies are different, the tactics are different, and someone could easily find one "incredibly fun" and the other "intensely boring".
- georgemcbay 13y agoYeah, I agree. From the article: "currently, there’s only one “Flappy Bird” knock-off in the top 20 on the iTunes App Store" Hard to take an article seriously when it unironically and somewhat derisively references Flappy Bird knock-offs considering Flappy Bird itself is a pretty direct knock-off of Piou Piou: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=air.pioupiou&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=air.pioupiou&h... Which itself is more arguably a knock-off of Helicopter Game, which is a dumbed down 1 button linear-rails horizontal version of Lunar Lander... and so on.
- Jare 13y agoI believe PiouPiou (the app and the website they put up) was released in February 2014 and their story of being ripped off by Flappy Bird is just a shameless lie for people who don't check dates.
- georgemcbay 13y agoIf that's true they also either hacked YouTube or created a time machine so they could go back to 2010 and post this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MpxmqejpR0Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MpxmqejpR0Q
- bertil 13y agoI’ve worked for one of the developers of Piou-Piou. The game was released in 2010, didn’t meet much success at the time, and like a handful of games from the same group was discontinued. The recent video was published after heated discussion on how Flappy Bird ripped them off (during which I wrote to them it was unlikely -- not sure they agree, to this day). They also made a handful of games that were successful, several that went through very public controversy about being copied from someone else; several that have been stolen quite blatantly (with the original developers nicknames in the function calls). That cycle hasn't stopped there: reverse-engineered a game for cheap, etc. I won’t give details because I don’t like talking to lawyers, but all was as transparent as those things can be. I’ll say here what I said then: if someone steals from you, there's always a slight difference that could be an improvement, take that; otherwise, every game has its own history. Learn and let it be.
- oneeyedpigeon 13y agoI've lost count of the number of different titles that Flappy Bird is supposedly a rip-off of.
- jmduke 13y agoI strongly disagree with this, and I've played a lot of both Threes and 2048. The only serious mechanical difference is starting off with 1s and 2s instead of 2s and 4s -- everything else is exactly the same (from a gameplay perspective: Threes of course has way more polish). I think it's incredibly disingenuous to say that the similarities are superficial. I mean, hell, 1024's marketing copy literally says "no need to pay for ThreesGames." https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/1024!/id823499224 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/1024!/id823499224
- cwyers 13y agoThat's not even a mechanical difference, the additive nature of the two is still the same. The biggest mechanical difference is Threes moves tiles one space at a time, while 2048 moves tiles as far as they can go.
- jmduke 13y agoYou're right, of course -- though the 1&2 vs. 2&4 is still a mechanical difference due to the random distribution of the new tiles. In Threes, you can be faced with a long string of 1s without seeing any 2s (and vice-versa); such a problem doesn't exist in 2048, since you can match the tiles with themselves.
- bgilroy26 13y agoThe difference between Threes and 2048 is that Threes moves the tiles on the board one space in the direction chosen by the player. In 2048, they move as far as they can go before being blocked by another tile or the sides of the board. The numbers on the tiles are not a serious mechanical difference.
- stevejohnson 13y agoPedantic corrections to follow (but useful ones, I hope). There is one substantive gameplay difference between Threes and ArbitraryPowerOfTwo. In Threes, a swipe moves the game board one square. In ArbitraryPowerOfTwo, a swipe applies gravity to the game board in the swipe's direction until it settles. I've played both, and that difference does not significantly affect gameplay or strategy.
- Bahamut 13y agoBejeweled takes away from Tetris Attack's depth while ripping the essential mechanic - it almost certainly is a clone.
- saurik 13y agoYet Bejeweled is in a way more difficult, as you can't reorganize the board: someone who's really good at Tetris Attack takes time to become good at Bejeweled, because you can't "build" structure... you have to legitimately find it, and then plan ahead to avoid accidentally destroying that structure. The tradeoff with Tetris Attack is that you can only move items horizontally: if you could move items vertically (as you can in Bejeweled) and also leave them in position (as you can in Tetris Attack) the game would no longer have any strategy left.