2 ms·
The analog wouldn't be a muslim wedding; it would be a Muslim religious ceremony. The proprietors in question clearly stated they would sell a birthday cake to
by humanrebar 13y ago
The analog wouldn't be a muslim wedding; it would be a Muslim religious ceremony.
The proprietors in question clearly stated they would sell a birthday cake to a gay couple. They wouldn't, however, sell them a wedding cake.
A better analogy would be whether a Muslim bakery could be forced to produce communion wafers. Or whether a baker would otherwise be forced to produce a cake containing speech he or she didn't agree with ("Happy Abortion!" or "Happy Bris!").
In my view, this issue is complex only because the position of the business owners in question is being elided.
- masklinn 13y ago> A better analogy would be whether a Muslim bakery could be forced to produce communion wafers. No, it is a terrible analogy: a muslim bakery wouldn't usually produce communion wafers. The bakery in question did usually produce wedding cakes[0], and refused to provide a usual service on grounds of sexual orientation (the bakery had no problem providing a wedding cake for a pair of dogs when asked). > In my view, this issue is complex only because the position of the business owners in question is being elided. The business owners repeatedly made their position clear: they had a strict policy against selling wedding cakes to same-sex couples based on their "reading of the Word of God." Their position is illegal in Colorado. [0] and wedding cakes were available for sampling
- humanrebar 13y agoRegardless, the result is that someone is refused their freedom of expression or forced to go out of business. You may be OK with that in this case, but let's call a spade a spade. This attitude is certainly part of the reason that gay marriage has faced such opposition. Banning the expression of one group of people for the sake of advocating the freedom of expression of another[1] is not a winning argument. [1] Not that marriage is only an act of expression.
- masklinn 13y ago> Regardless, the result is that someone is refused their freedom of expression They can express whatever the fuck they want, what they can not do is discriminate against a protected class. It's been that way for the last 50 years. Don't like that? Don't be a public accommodation. > This attitude is certainly part of the reason that gay marriage has faced such opposition. No, that's just an excuse for the underlying bigotry. As it was back in the 60s.
- Lockyy 13y agoNo, it's closer to a Christian bakery refusing to sell communion wafers to a Muslim because they aren't Christian. The problem is refusing an existing service to someone based upon them as a person. Not refusing to provide a service you don't usually provide.