5 ms·
There's literally no daylight between those stances and claims to the contrary are disingenuous. Worse yet, there isn't even a good reason to hold such a stanc
by eropple 13y ago
There's literally no daylight between those stances and claims to the contrary are disingenuous.
Worse yet, there isn't even a good reason to hold such a stance.
- burntsushi 13y agoOf course there is. Being against State privileged marriage automatically makes you against State privilege gay marriage. I don't know if that's the case for Eich, but it is at least a counter-example to your claim.
- eropple 13y ago"Nobody should have it, but especially they shouldn't" is what that functionally boils down to in the world of the real. That's a really bad position to hold, too.
- burntsushi 13y ago> "Nobody should have it, but especially they shouldn't" The way you've phrased it specifically makes it look like the stance is targeting gays. That's disingenuous. Here's another phrasing: "Governments should not be involved in marriage. Increasing their involvement in marriage will only make matters worse." This is clearly not anti-gay. This is a sufficient counter-example to your claim even if you think it's a "bad position" to hold. (I don't think it's a great position to hold either. I don't think governments should be involved in marriage, but I'm pragmatic about it and think they should open the doors to whatever kind of cohabitation people want. This includes polyamory.) Basically what I'm saying is that being against State privileged gay marriage doesn't have to be anti-gay. It can be anti-State. I grant that most people who advocate from this position are hypocrites and are probably using it to mask more sinister motivations, but that doesn't make this reasoning invalid.
- eropple 13y agoTo be completely honest: I don't believe anyone has that position in good faith.
- burntsushi 13y agoI certainly know people who do. But then again, I travel in voluntaryist circles, so I'm predisposed to exactly the kind of people who might have that position. There aren't many.
- waterlesscloud 13y agoWell, you're just wrong about that. I'm personally aware of people who do.
- anonymoushn 13y agoI oppose all marriage, but I am willing to be pragmatic about this, and will vote for both legislation that liberalizes marriage and legislation that bans it.
- eropple 13y agoSure, and that's a rational, coherent viewpoint that doesn't require you to want to keep gays as lesser citizens. The viewpoint espoused by burntsushi requires it. I don't care if you think the state institution of marriage should be abolished--I even kind of agree--but if your idea of "holding the line" is "nah, fuck those people", you have jank in your worldview and I suspect very much I can identify it.
- burntsushi 13y ago> The viewpoint espoused by burntsushi requires it. I don't hold that viewpoint. I was merely demonstrating that one can be against gay marriage without being anti-gay. > "nah, fuck those people" Uh, no. I'm not doing it to those people. Government is. Virtually every law regulating social behaviors (whether it's created or repealed) requires oppressing some class of people. In the case of State privileged marriage, it oppresses everyone who can't or won't marry but still want benefits only available to married persons.
- SimHacker 13y ago"I have no chance of achieving my overreaching goal of abolishing marriage for everyone, but by teaming up with religious bigots and homophobes, who I agree with about preventing gay marriage, but disagree with about preventing straight marriage, at least I can achieve a small part of my unattainable goal by perpetuating discrimination against a small minority of historically oppressed people, because they have less power to defend their right to marriage than the general population."