4 ms·
> So now anyone who opposes gay marriage is homophobic? Yup, same as anyone who opposes interracial marriage is racist. There's not a minimum threshold of big
by PhasmaFelis 13y ago
> So now anyone who opposes gay marriage is homophobic?
Yup, same as anyone who opposes interracial marriage is racist.
There's not a minimum threshold of bigotry. You don't get to say "How bigoted can I be without people calling me a bigot? ...I can't be bigoted at all?!? That's not fair!"
- lttlrck 13y agoYou cannot conflate bigotry with homophobia. People may simple be bigoted towards gay marriage, but hold no strong opinion on the individuals themselves. That this is a possible stance is self-evident given the current legal situation.
- masklinn 13y ago> You cannot conflate bigotry with homophobia. If their specific bigotry is homophobic, why would they not be conflatable? I mean people may simple be bigoted towards interracial marriage, but hold no strong opinion on the individuals themselves. That this is a possible stance is self-evident given the current legal situation. (and apparently not at all racist)
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoHow would you react to the statement "I'm not racist, I just don't think blacks and whites should be allowed to marry"? If you oppose equal civil rights for group X, you are bigoted against group X. There are certainly different degrees of bigots--I'd much rather deal with someone who favors most civil rights other than interracial marriage than someone who thinks black people were better off as slaves--but they are all still bigots.
- btilly 13y agoYeah, no. That's an impossible standard. How do you feel about abortion? If you're against it, then you are seen as bigoted against women's right to their own body. If you're for it, then you're seen as bigoted against the rights of unborn children to not be murdered. And even if you could think that way, you shouldn't. Why not? Read http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html for why I don't want to put such mental blinders on.
- vectorpush 13y agoNo. The abortion analogy is terrible. Abortion is a muddy issue because it pits the rights of the mother against the rights of the fetus. The crux of the argument basically comes down to whether one believes that a fetus should have the same legal protections as a human. If the mother is forced to carry the pregnancy to term, she loses the freedom to make her own medical decisions, if she is allowed to terminate her pregnancy, then the fetus will never be born. We have not yet devised a way to resolve this conflict. Contrast this with the gay marriage debate. There is no conflict. Gay marriage does not affect its opponents in any capacity. A married gay couple does not infringe on anybody else's right to be married. Opposition to gay marriage is completely arbitrary and rooted in discrimination in all cases, there just isn't any reason why one should care, and even less of a reason why the government should take that judgement into consideration. Any religious, traditional, or cultural opposition to gay marriage is completely moot since marriage is not even real thing, it's simply a legal status with the same name as a historical tradition.
- btilly 13y agoMy point is about bigotry, not gay marriage. The muddiness of the issue is part of the point, we all have opinions on rights that should exist, and it is easy to throw the word "bigot" at anyone who disagrees with us. Therefore a blanket dismissal of all forms of bigotry easily becomes a straightjacket that limits our ability to think. Take that one step farther and you wind up with silliness such as an unwillingness to discuss obvious gender mental differences such as the differential performance under the Piaget water level test. (See http://books.google.com/books?id=ocl5AgAAQBAJ&pg=PA130&lpg=PA130&dq=piaget+water+level+test&source=bl&ots=WAjQB7smbq&sig=_mH7Q2udLgHuYNvHAfjcYLj7Q1E&hl=en&sa=X&ei=xb0wU9a-No7zoATbkYKABQ&ved=0CEgQ6AEwBw#v=onepage&q=piaget%20water%20level%20test&f=false http://books.google.com/books?id=ocl5AgAAQBAJ&pg=PA130&lpg=P... in the likely event that you don't know what I am talking about.) And that leads to things like Larry Summers getting fired over fallout from his discussing the best available research on a controversial topic. Therefore I'm against a blanket, "You're not allowed any trace of bigotry." Strongly against it. It limits people's ability to think. Now I can see you responding that this example has nothing to do with gay marriage. So let me give a real example tying that one. My opinion is that homophobia ties to the uncanny valley (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncanny_valley http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncanny_valley for what THAT is) which is the feeling of revulsion that virtually all of us have for the "almost human". (Different people having different definitions of "almost".) Having broached the topic, we can discuss emotional reactions to other races, disabled people, various disfigurements, and the ways in which horror movies play on the natural phenomena. But wait, what can of worms did I just open? I suggested a connection between widespread homophobia and an innate phenomena that causes the vast majority of humans to feel revulsion under the right circumstances. And it is a pretty strong revulsion - seeing that which you dislike will, like it or not, be about as palatable as stepping in a pile of shit. This really does affect others. (If you argue that it affects others because they are bigots, I can't disagree...but a lot of people are so affected.) Pretty much everyone who I've really had the conversation with has wound up realizing at some point that there is stuff which they personally respond with revulsion. And some of that stuff results in their having trouble not discriminating. You can try to consciously try not to act on that revulsion, which usually leads to an overreaction and reverse discrimination. But the roots of at least some sorts of bigotry are something that seems to be built in to pretty much all of us - certainly me included. But if you've conceptualized anyone who has any trace of bigotry as unequivocally bad, then this is not a conversation that you're able to have. Because at some point you're going to have to face ways that you resemble people you don't like. And THAT is an example of why I don't want the mental blinders that keep me from even trying to think about homophobic people in terms that are more sophisticated than, "They are awful people." (For the record, I am straight, I am not homophobic, and I voted against prop 8. Also my sister has some gay friends who wish I'd reconsider the "straight" bit...)