3 ms·
Basic Income directly makes labor more expensive (by lowering the opportunity cost for other activities). It would also increase the price of scarce resources.
by dllthomas 13y ago
Basic Income directly makes labor more expensive (by lowering the opportunity cost for other activities). It would also increase the price of scarce resources. There are inputs to production that are neither of these. Even so, it's undoubtedly true that we could set so high a basic income that it would impact production enough that we'd see runaway inflation rather than any positive outcome. I'm not necessarily convinced $20k/yr is that high, but I personally favor a much lower number (~7k/yr).
- pm24601 13y ago> runaway inflation .... You say "runaway inflation" like its a bad, immediate prospect. Right now we are so far away from that boogie man.
- dllthomas 13y agoLike I said, I don't make any claim that it's likely for the numbers given. There're clearly numbers for which it would be a bad, immediate prospect ($100k/yr, $1m/yr, ...). I'm not convinced either way about $20k/yr, though I do think that's a bit high in our present situation.
- ThomPete 13y agoBut might actually increase the amount of people who create their own business. That isn't a bad tradeoff.
- dllthomas 13y agoOh, by no means do I think BI is a bad tradeoff. I just want to be clear about the benefits and the drawbacks. Regarding entrepreneurship in particular: the reduction in risk will tend to push toward an increase; the reduction in pressure to work at all will tend toward a decrease. At sensible levels of BI, I expect the former to win out and that we'd see an increase overall.
- sharemywin 13y agoMost of the service industry would disapear over nigiht. you think if you paid people more than they make now that they show up for a fex bucks more: dlivery drivers, wait staff, hotel cleaning people, gas station service personel, grocery stores.
- dllthomas 13y agoA lot of people in the service industry are presently working two jobs. Basically replacing one of those jobs doesn't seem to mean they'd be likely to quit the other. Without question it would substantially effect the supply of labor there, though - particularly if it's as high as $20k/yr.