7 ms·
Basic Income is an illusion
If we pay $20,000 to 300 million people = $6 trillion. If we still need to do or get done all the work that needs done. We pay $13 trillion each year out to labor. So how do people become incentivized to do the jobs that need done?(Think low end service jobs.) simple prices raise until people need more money than the basic income provides to survive.
- ThomPete 13y agoYou have to deduct the overhead to control targeted welfare, plus the fact that most people will be paying most of that back in taxes. Alse keep in mind, removing stuff like capital gains will also help bring in even more. With Unconditional Basic Income it is always beneficial to work. Even if you only work for a couple of months a year it's still beneficial to you.
- jcalvinowens 13y ago> With Unconditional Basic Income it is always beneficial to work. Exactly. A UBI would encourage people to work, since working just means you make more money. The biggest drawback of the current system in the US is that it penalizes you for working: if you start to make more money, your benefits go away and you might as well have not started working.
- dllthomas 13y agoStrictly, a transition to UBI from conditional assistance would encourage people currently receiving conditional assistance to work. People who are not currently receiving assistance would have a smaller incentive to engage in paid work than at present. This probably has both positive and negative consequences.
- ThomPete 13y agoIt's not the purpose of UBI to get EVERYONE to work. The purpose is to get as many as possible to work and not have to deal with controlling who "deserves" what, who cheats etc. It's totally fine that some people don't work as long as the majority of people will. In many ways we already have a form of BI today, it's just conditional and have the negative effect of branding people, keeping them in their social status.
- dllthomas 13y ago"It's not the purpose of UBI to get EVERYONE to work." Never made any claim - or implication, so far as I can see - that it was. 'The purpose is to get as many as possible to work and not have to deal with controlling who "deserves" what, who cheats etc.' I think the purpose is to ensure that everyone has some basic resources to build upon, to stabilize consumption, to shift power a bit toward labor in the jobs market, and to provide something of a safety net. It is preferable to conditional assistance because it doesn't have any cliffs and there's less room for political nonsense than with targeted assistance, but that's not really the purpose of the program - those are equally attributes of a system with no UBI but also no other welfare programs. "It's totally fine that some people don't work as long as the majority of people will." I agree with the sentiment, not the precise formulation. It is totally fine if some people don't work as long as enough work that we can produce enough to meet demand. What portion of the population that is depends on a whole lot of factors (and in the longest term will probably shrink). I don't see that it has any particular relationship with 50% ("the the majority of the people") - currently it probably needs to be quite a bit more than that. "In many ways we already have a form of BI today, it's just conditional and have the negative effect of branding people, keeping them in their social status." I wouldn't call it "a form of BI", but I would say that many of the supposed evils of BI are already present in our current system.
- jcalvinowens 13y ago> It is totally fine if some people don't work as long as enough work that we can produce enough to meet demand. That's precisely the point: it creates a market for labor that does not currently exist. If there were not enough workers to meet demand, the suppliers would have to increase salaries until enough of them decided the money was worth going to work. A UBI allows natural market forces to do things that we have to do with regulation now. Minimum wage could be eradicated with a UBI, for example, since everybody enough to live on. Real wages for unskilled workers would be forced much higher, which I think would be a very good thing for the economy as a whole.
- dllthomas 13y ago
- fit2rule 13y agoI'd rather see an effort to scratch all forms of income tax, which is the real problem with the worlds' economy today: plain theft of income. If we had a more aggressive movement to eradicate income tax and tax SPENDING, we'd have far less need for the welfare classes to be kept in their debilitating position ..
- ThomPete 13y agoTheft? Your property "rights" (and other rights) are guaranteed by the state. If you remove the state you will have to defend it yourself. Do you really think you would be able to do that?
- rainmaking 13y agoI could hire some goons.
- ThomPete 13y agoSo could I and if you sat on some important resource I didn't even have to.
- rainmaking 13y agoYou mean, just like it is right now? At least I get to chose the goons I hire. Presumably those with poor negotiation leverage and -skills would go out of business rather quickly.
- fit2rule 13y agoDa, Komrad. I do believe that the state can still protect me without having to rob me first.
- mcv 13y agoHow would they pay for it, if you deny them any income? A civilized society costs money. Police costs money. Roads costs money. Inspectors for all sorts of safety standards cost money. Education costs money. Without some form of tax, anyone would be free to rob you, you wouldn't be able to go anywhere without roads, you wouldn't know if the house you want to buy is actually safe to live in, and everybody would be stupid. Go try it out. There are countries where you don't have to pay any tax. Go see how you like it there.
- rprospero 13y agoI'm not sure that I follow your argument. Specifically, you asked the question: "So how do people become incentivized to do the jobs that need done?" Most proposals I've seen for basic income operate under the idea that people are encouraged to perform jobs by being paid, as it is under the current system. Would you quit your job for a guaranteed 20k a year? I wouldn't. I'd like to have money for travel, which would be more difficult on that salary. Besides, I rather like my job.
- sharemywin 13y agoMy point is the service industry disappears. retail clerks, wait staff, gas station attendants, cleaners. Nobody does that work because they like it. Most of the people in the service industry work to get by. By choice or because they have to.
- ThomPete 13y agoGiven that it will always be beneficial to work if you need extra money you take those jobs. It's always beneficial to work. But those jobs are disappearing anyway.
- dllthomas 13y agoBasic Income directly makes labor more expensive (by lowering the opportunity cost for other activities). It would also increase the price of scarce resources. There are inputs to production that are neither of these. Even so, it's undoubtedly true that we could set so high a basic income that it would impact production enough that we'd see runaway inflation rather than any positive outcome. I'm not necessarily convinced $20k/yr is that high, but I personally favor a much lower number (~7k/yr).
- pm24601 13y ago> runaway inflation .... You say "runaway inflation" like its a bad, immediate prospect. Right now we are so far away from that boogie man.
- dllthomas 13y agoLike I said, I don't make any claim that it's likely for the numbers given. There're clearly numbers for which it would be a bad, immediate prospect ($100k/yr, $1m/yr, ...). I'm not convinced either way about $20k/yr, though I do think that's a bit high in our present situation.
- ThomPete 13y agoBut might actually increase the amount of people who create their own business. That isn't a bad tradeoff.
- dllthomas 13y agoOh, by no means do I think BI is a bad tradeoff. I just want to be clear about the benefits and the drawbacks. Regarding entrepreneurship in particular: the reduction in risk will tend to push toward an increase; the reduction in pressure to work at all will tend toward a decrease. At sensible levels of BI, I expect the former to win out and that we'd see an increase overall.
- sharemywin 13y agoMost of the service industry would disapear over nigiht. you think if you paid people more than they make now that they show up for a fex bucks more: dlivery drivers, wait staff, hotel cleaning people, gas station service personel, grocery stores.
- jbb555 13y ago>> Would you quit your job for a guaranteed 20k a year? I wouldn't. Probably yes. I've worked for 25 years. I have a good amount of savings. But not enough to retire on. If you gave me $20k a year I'd have enough to retire on right now. So it would cost you $20k a year to pay me not to work, plus probably 50% more than that in lost taxes. Not a chance of this working.
- dllthomas 13y agoIt doesn't rely on there being no one in your position, so it doesn't follow from your example that there is "not a chance of this working." We want some people in your circumstance - able to comfortably step aside when we don't know what to put your labor towards, ready to rejoin the work force when we figure it out (as determined by whether you want what we're offering to pay you). Though, for the record, I think $20k is high for our present situation.
- mcv 13y agoI'd probably quit my job, but I wouldn't stop working. I'd start doing work that _I_ want. I'd make cool stuff, rather than boring corporate websites. And who knows? Some of that cool stuff might even make me more money than corporate websites would. And with 20k a year, I could afford to take that risk. Basic Income would be absolutely fantastic for starting entrepreneurs.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- plurinshael 13y agoConsider the fact that for some time, the quantitative easing program has been "printing" $80 billion per month by buying US treasuries from wealthy people / firms. Say what you will about the necessity to print money, strategies about monetary policy, etc, this unequivocally creates an artificially high demand for these assets in a way that wealthy firms are able to generate profit from. If we're giving away money, let's give it to people whose marginal propensity to consume goods and services is double or triple to whom we're giving it now. I realize we have now "tapered" our buying down to $65 billion a month. For reference, using US census data for adults 18 and over, 65bil / 240mil = $270 per month. It's not a living wage, but a great majority of recipients would immediately inject that money back into the economy.
- sharemywin 13y ago...consuming goods which would increase prices. prices would go up because they would need paid more to do their jobs(think service industry cause they ain't doin' it cause they like it).
- ThomPete 13y agoAgain, technology drives prices down not up.
- pm24601 13y agoYou got the Basic Income concept wrong. If someone takes a job, they get the income from that job IN ADDITION to the Basic Income. Basic Income is paid out unconditionally - i.e. no means testing. Rich or poor, employed or unemployed: you get the money. This is similar to what: 1. Alaska does with its oil tax revenue. 2. U.S. and some states do with the Earned Income Tax Credit. Why have Basic Income? It would replace: 1. Food stamps. 2. Unemployment insurance 3. WIC 4. Section 8. ... and related bureaucracies because the money is unconditional, no government agency is needed to "validate" the person is poor enough to get the money. There would be no stigma attached to receiving the money, no requirements on how the money was being spent. Just like Alaskans can spend their oil money how they want and people getting the fully-refundable EITC can spend that money how they want.
- sharemywin 13y agoI get that. My point is the service industry disappears. retail clerks, wait staff, gas station attendants, cleaners. Nobody does that work because they like it. Most of the people in the service industry work to get by. By choice or because they have to.
- ThomPete 13y agoMuch of that is going away because of automation, which is one of the reasons UBI is beginning to be seen as a potential solution to that problem. I.e. you are going to see an increasing number of people who have no background in tech, design, science, engineering, math etc. and therefore have no new potential of jobs and those they can get are Walmart which doesn't pay it's employees enough and thus put a big portion of the economic burden back on society.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> My point is the service industry disappears. retail clerks, wait staff, gas station attendants, cleaners. Nobody does that work because they like it. No, they do it because they need the money to live the lifestyle they want -- and often need more than the reasonable level at which UBI would be set any time in the near future. Otherwise, no one would work the hours in those industries to make more than even the (very high for UBI suggestions in the near term) $20,000 proposed in the first post in this thread, yet many people do. (Of course, lots of people "work" in those fields because they are either owners or immediately family of owners who stand to benefit, in the long or short term, from capital returns of the business, so they aren't working strictly for the wages, and UBI has little effect on them at all -- except perhaps to raise the wages that their big-chain competitors have to pay and increase their opportunity.) So, no, for a whole lot of reasons I don't see UBI killing the service industry.