4 ms·
Because we've been hearing this "the old continent with its big government and socialist laws is dying" crap for generations, and so far the only major fuck-ups
by Silhouette 13y ago
Because we've been hearing this "the old continent with its big government and socialist laws is dying" crap for generations, and so far the only major fuck-ups have been in the ideologically driven attempts to be more like the US.
The Greeks just called and asked if you could give them a loan.
I think you're right that there are multiple roads that lead to success, but not all roads do. The economic policies of quite a few European nations over the past decade or two have been unsustainable, and as we have now confirmed the hard way, that means sooner or later things break spectacularly. There's not much point comparing working conditions between Europe and the US when one of these places has widespread unemployment and there is literally rioting on the streets, as was the case not very long ago.
As 'gadders observed, there have been other economic policy decisions in (parts of) Europe that had nothing to do with emulating the US, sounded positive, but turned out to be crazy too.
- marcusf 13y ago> There's not much point comparing working conditions between Europe and the US when one of these places has widespread unemployment and there is literally rioting on the streets, as was the case not very long ago. Which continent are you talking about now? Sounds like both?
- Silhouette 13y agoThe situations in the US vs. the European nations that have been in serious trouble recently are barely comparable. Even in the past year or so, with fears of further recession fading and growth returning to the PIIGS group, Greek unemployment is still running at over 27%, while the US is running at under 7%. Similarly, while the US and elsewhere saw significant protests as part of the Occupy movement, they were mostly peaceful in nature. The violence seen on the streets of Greece around 2010-2012 as severe austerity measures were taken was on a different scale entirely.
- kiiski 13y agoBut isn't that exactly a result of trying to be more "USA" (by having an economic union)? Besides, comparing US with a single European country is pretty pointless. One could easily turn the table around by choosing Norway instead of Greece.
- marcusf 13y agoWhat I took offence to was comparing Europe as a whole to America. It doesn't necessarily make sense given the different make-up of the continents. I have to volt-face that a bit though in that I was a bit surprised at both unemployment rate and labor force participation rates between EU and US. I.e. this graph didn't look like what I was prejudiced to think: http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SL.TLF.CACT.ZS/countries/EU-US-GR-SE-DE?display=graph http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SL.TLF.CACT.ZS/countries... It's crazy listening to US rhetoric about the job market given your relatively low unemployment, high labor force participation and relatively high average salaries.
- seabee 13y agoNobody is comparing working conditions between Greece and the US, so why knock down that particular strawman? Unless you believe the economic policies of the European countries that do get talked about e.g. France, Germany, the Nordics, (the UK should count but it's not very interesting), are unsustainable and about to erupt in rioting over high unemployment, I think there is much to learn in both directions.
- Silhouette 13y agoI think perhaps you replied to the wrong post? The GGP post I replied to was explicitly contrasting the US with Europe (not once but twice clarifying that wasn't referring to France alone), and it specifically mentioned working conditions. Also, while Greece is the strongest example, you could probably substitute any of the PIIGS group and my counter-argument would still hold to a degree: when insufficiently moderated, the socialist-leaning economic policies that are popular in parts of Europe have not been very successful recently. There are many possible balances that might work, but neither extremely socialist nor extremely capitalist economic policies tend to fare well over the long term.
- TheCoelacanth 13y agoNone of the PIIGS were extremely socialist. The most socialist-leaning countries in Europe (e.g. Denmark and Norway) are still going strong.
- Silhouette 13y agoNone of the PIIGS were extremely socialist. Please note that I never suggested they were. My intended point was only that generally socialist-leaning countries usually need to have something to balance that inclination or over time things tend to start going wrong. In successful examples, such as we see in Scandinavia, competent government and generally good public services appear to be sufficient. People see a decent return on the relatively high levels of taxation they pay. Also, while the overall tax burden is relatively high, most of these countries tend to have a relatively soft touch with businesses that makes them nevertheless a reasonably attractive place to operate. In less successful examples, such as we saw in Greece, the same sentiment is present, but the government failed to actually collect the taxes and provide effective public services. Black markets and corruption were everywhere, and a vicious cycle set in, leading to excessive borrowing by the government and the end result we're all familiar with. I'd suggest that similar factors were at work in Italy, with so much corruption and general incompetence in the government that they essentially gave up on democracy and wound up with an appointed technocrat at the helm. Portugal, also, had some very dubious financial management at government level, much of it based on excessive employment in the public sector and dubious arrangements based on public-private partnerships, and of course the problems with the banks that led up to their economic crisis. I concede that perhaps it wasn't correct to identify the PIIGS as a group in this context, because not all of their recent economic troubles started the same way. Even so, several of them have shared striking similarities, both in being generally over-reliant on an inefficient public sector before the crisis and in being relatively difficult places to try and start a new business since then.
- bowlofpetunias 13y agoMost of Europe has been playing this game for centuries. Almost everything people consider typically European, from food, culture to social-economic policies, has mostly been imported and adopted from countries and cultures outside of Europe. It's this openness to change, this constant iteration instead of desperately holding on to the "one true way" (something typical not only for cultures that rise and fall, but also something that seems to be hindering the US when it comes to implementing necessary change) is the essence of the enduring wealth of Western-Europe. There is no one European way, just constant evolution until a new successful road is found. The riots in the streets and social unrest, which are nothing new or unusual in Europe, are a part of that process, not a sign of deterioration. (And unemployment figures are hard to compare when what is considered employment in the US is considered exploitation of people below the poverty line in Europe...) The economic policies of "a decade or two" are nothing. A blip. European countries can completely tilt social-economic policy within a generation because none of it is tied to their fundamental identities. You visit some European countries now you would find it hard to believe they were strictly communist less than a generation ago. Whatever traditions European nations have, they go much deeper than the favorite social-economic policy du jour. It's something Americans seem to find very difficult to separate. The US has tied it's identity to fundamental social-economic values and ideologies. For European nations, social-economic policy is a changeable as the weather.
- Silhouette 13y agoThere is certainly a lot of diversity in political and economic views in Europe, and by European standards the political and economic mainstream in the US are very narrow, with relatively little difference between the two big parties or the economics they promote. I think you are overstating how fast things change in Europe and how much has been imported and adopted from outside. With the arrival of the EU and its subsequent expansion to bring many more countries into "Europe", the mix has changed, but if you look at "old Europe" the character and general philosophy of each nation hasn't really changed all that much for quite a long time. The Germans are still industrious: they believe in making stuff well and follow a somewhat capitalist philosophy. The UK and most of northern Europe have similar tendencies, though some of these places have drifted away from manufacturing and toward service sectors more than others in recent decades. In contrast, the French are heavily socialist, and southern Europe has similar tendencies.
- pessimizer 13y agoThe Greeks put in the most hours in Europe. The problem that the Greeks had was that the Germans kept loaning them money to buy things from the Germans, and that they couldn't adjust their currency in relations to the Germans in order to react to that. It's not that they don't work and rely on an economy with 'excessive' transfers.