3 ms·
Now, are you telling me these Superheroes of Business will look at a progressive tax rate and say, "you know what, if I thought I could make $3 million after 3
by Silhouette 13y ago
Now, are you telling me these Superheroes of Business will look at a progressive tax rate and say, "you know what, if I thought I could make $3 million after 3 years of hard work, I would do it... but since it'll only be $2.7, I guess I'm gonna stick to my day job where I make $150k/year." Because that's the logical conclusion of what you're saying.
No, I'm telling you that people who are capable of and considering starting a business, several years earlier in their career than the kind of relatively uncommon success story you're talking about where millions of dollars are flying around, are going to look at a progressive tax rate where a high proportion of their earnings if they are really successful are going to get stolen away by the state in taxes and they're going to think twice. Some of them are then going to decide it's not worth it and just stick with being someone's probably relatively well-compensated employee, which is bad for their national economy because usually small businesses drive a substantial proportion of growth. Others are going to move to a more supportive environment and start their business there instead, which is bad for the original economy, though good for the new one.
You're selling lottery tickets where there is no jackpot, and people who understand maths aren't going to play that game. Most people who are capable of starting a successful business (and anyone who professionally invests in young businesses) understand maths.
I for one would rather pay 50% on my 1.5mil than 25% on 150k, should it come to that.
OK, but what about 75% of your 1.5mil? What about 90%, a rate we actually had in the UK for much of the 1950s and 1960s? Or how about 98% on your investment income, again a rate we really had for a while? Still want to invest in a 20% share of a new business that might make a few million in this country, or would you rather invest in a SV start-up, or in energy and natural resource production in a developing economy, or any of the other vastly more profitable opportunities that would then be available to you?
At some point, the numbers become prohibitive. The interesting question is when that happens, not whether it does.