3 ms·
One of the frustrations I have with the Snowden leaks is that we see some of the process of intelligence gathering but we don't see the results. This is the pr
by CamperBob2 13y ago
One of the frustrations I have with the Snowden leaks is that we see some of the process of intelligence gathering but we don't see the results.
This is the problem of utilitarianism. For any action of significance, there are both short-term results and long-term results. Some of those consequences, particularly the long-term ones, may not be predictable. Some of them may not be to your liking, even if you thought you were maximizing a utility function when you committed to the action.
Some of the consequences may be pretty fucking disastrous, in fact.
Hacking Huawei strikes me as one of those things that seems like a good idea when it's proposed in a locked-down SCIF at Fort Meade, and it may still seem like a good idea to some when it's disclosed in the New York Times. But I can't begin to imagine any long-term upside. I believe that if these people are left unchecked, their actions will lead to the mutually-assured destruction of privacy, or at least the sundering of the Internet.
- mpyne 13y ago> But I can't begin to imagine any long-term upside. I believe that if these people are left unchecked, their actions will lead to the mutually-assured destruction of privacy, or at least the sundering of the Internet. Who is in the set of "these people" though? For instance, how do you think Huawei obtained much of their IP in the first place? If hacking will lead to the destruction of privacy then the U.S. is not the sole point of responsibility here. In fact it's already the other way around completely; states hacking other states is a given, it's already happening and has been happening for awhile. Nothing NSA does or doesn't do will change the actions of the rest of the governments around the world. I think you're right that the Internet will sunder itself, but if you're going to start pointing fingers then get ready to have a long list of pointees.