3 ms·
This is a big problem with current envy-driven politics surrounding wealth. This is not envy driven. Not wanting bonuses for bankers who were bailed out by pu
by mpweiher 13y ago
This is a big problem with current envy-driven politics surrounding wealth.
This is not envy driven. Not wanting bonuses for bankers who were bailed out by public money has to do with bonus-driven bad decisions being a fundamental cause of the crash that cost everyone else trillions of dollars in wealth, economic growth, unemployment benefits and bailouts. Look up "moral hazard", and note that they are up to the same shenanigans that got us into this mess.
Furthermore, if the banks are, effectively, government guaranteed, then bankers should be paid as government employees. Greater pay is for greater skill and risk, their risk is borne by everyone but themselves and as for skill... So it is only proper (and not "envy") for the taxpayers to get those bonuses.
..old money children who have inherited a fortune but seem to have contributed little of value themselves
This is also a huge economic and social problem, no need to invoke "envy". The moneyed elites have started to decouple themselves from the rest of the world. I went to a prep school in Michigan where this was quite apparent, and scary. There was also a recent study that warned that this decoupling of the elites from everyone else could lead to (or contribute heavily to) the collapse of civilization [1]. For an artistic rendition, see "Elysium". What's so scary about that film is not the dystopian outlook, but rather how real a lot of it already feels.
They're envious of highly paid sporting or artistic celebrities who get more salary in a week than most of us make in a year.
Again, there are good economic arguments for this being a problem. Pay way in excess of the ability to consume creates a huge overhang in liquidity with which people start to gamble in the international financial casino, creating instability[1] See also "Giant Pool of Money"[2]
And so they support punitive rates of tax for those who earn noticeably more than they do
The rates are not punitive. They are stabilizing. Where this rate starts is a good question to which I don't have a good answer.
Unfortunately, what that usually does in practice is hit highly qualified professionals or modestly successful entrepreneurs
Not according to any statistics I have seen. References?
However, the people these punitive taxes don't hit are the ones that the popular moneylust craves, because the super-rich are the people who have the flexibility to move their assets and/or themselves around to avoid high-tax environments. Absent serious international co-operation to overcome the naturally competitive tax environment that today's globalised society creates, these people will continue to be super-rich no matter what
So should we not do this because it is wrong or because it won't work? It seems it can't work if we don't start somewhere. Certainly finance has globalized, so it seems it is time for enforcement to catch up. This seems to start happening, see the crackdown on Switzerland as a tax-haven/money-laundering center.
[1] http://www.sesync.org/sites/default/files/resources/motesharrei-rivas-kalnay.pdf http://www.sesync.org/sites/default/files/resources/moteshar...
[2] http://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=n&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.spiegel.de%2Fwirtschaft%2Fhoeness-und-die-finanzkrise-kolumne-von-wolfgang-muenchau-a-958205.html http://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=n&pre...
[3] http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/355/the-giant-pool-of-money http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/355/t...
- Silhouette 13y agoLooking at the replies to my previous post, I'm guessing my choice of words had connotations for some readers that I didn't intend. My point was merely that a lot of the people arguing for high tax rates for above average earners today seem to be doing so in the belief that they will be collecting more money from the super-rich, whom they regard for whatever reason as being legitimate targets. However, the reality is that it's usually not the bankers with million pound/dollar bonuses or the pop stars flying to their concert on a private jet who are ever going to be paying those rates, because they all have sufficient mobility to escape the high tax rates by moving their assets and/or themselves elsewhere. So, I think it's more likely to be those who are significantly wealthier than average but not super-rich who get hit by these rates, and many of those people are self-made and the lucky ones. For example, while I'm not an expert on French taxation, I know that in the UK right now there is considerable debate about a 40% marginal tax rate for those earning above the higher rate threshold, because that threshold has been steadily reduced in real terms to the point where unlike the situation when that rate was first introduced, today quite a few people working full time in ordinary professional jobs would get caught in that bracket. (For context, with the latest tax bands and income levels, well over 4M taxpayers will be caught in that bracket, from a total population approaching 64M.) Then there's a marginal 60% rate for a while when you hit £100k, which is certainly a very nice salary to be earning, but at a little over three times the national average it's hardly super-rich. It does cover the senior positions in some professional and executive management roles, but it also catches the entrepreneur who takes a couple of years of very low salary (forfeiting their ability to take more salary at lower marginal tax rates, of course) and then makes good on their business and is able to draw a larger salary the next year. If you're interested in what people in different relatively well-paid professions really earn, you might find this helpful; it looks like being a doctor or a pilot is a promising option if you don't fancy the management path: http://www.theguardian.com/money/2013/dec/18/what-are-the-best-paid-jobs-uk-2013 http://www.theguardian.com/money/2013/dec/18/what-are-the-be... In short, I believe a lot of people don't think much of the super-rich, and they would be happy to see them get dinged for more tax. Sometimes there is some objective justification for this, but if anyone reading this thinks there's really no envy involved, I've got a nice second hand car to sell them. In any case, a lot of the people keen on the higher tax rates probably don't realise who is really going to wind up paying them, and how little effect they really have on the super-rich.