4 ms·
My favorite part of the whole flapperdoodle: John Holdren's fisking of Roger Pielke[1]. Best quote: "Senator Sessions quoted from testimony before the environm
by mcguire 13y ago
My favorite part of the whole flapperdoodle: John Holdren's fisking of Roger Pielke[1]. Best quote:
"Senator Sessions quoted from testimony before the environment and Public Works Committee the previous July by Dr. Roger Pielke.... Specifically, the Senator read the following passages from Dr. Pielke’s written testimony:
"'It is misleading, and just plain incorrect, to claim that disasters associated with hurricanes, tornadoes, floods or droughts have increased on climate timescales either in the United States or globally. Drought has “for the most part, become shorter, less, frequent, and cover a smaller portion
of the U.S. over the last century”....'
"Footnotes in the testimony attribute the [statement] in quotation marks [...] to the US Climate Change Science Program’s 2008 report on extremes in North America....
"...[A]ny reference to the CCSP 2008 report in this context should include not just the sentence highlighted in Dr. Pielke’s testimony but also the sentence that follows immediately in the relevant passage from that document and which relates specifically to the American West. Here are the two sentences in their entirety (http://downloads.globalchange.gov/sap/sap3- http://downloads.globalchange.gov/sap/sap3-
3/Brochure-CCSP-3-3.pdf):
"'Similarly, long-term trends (1925-2003) of hydrologic droughts based on model derived soil moisture and runoff show that droughts have, for the most part, become shorter, less frequent, and cover a smaller portion of the U.S. over the last century (Andreadis and Lettenmaier, 2006). The main exception is the Southwest and parts of the interior of the
West, where increased temperature has led to rising drought trends (Groisman et al., 2004; Andreadis and Lettenmaier, 2006).'"
Yes, Pielke argued ¬P by carefully picking a quote immediately next to a statement of P.
Extra credit for the mention of "Dr. Roy Spencer of the University of Alabama", who is the smarmiest goof-ball I've ever heard present. Really, no one is a bigger fan of contrarian scientists than I am; one of the best things Einstein ever did was to ensure the quantum mechanicists had their shit together. But starting off your talk by referring to everyone else in your field as "politicians and scientists who want to be politicians" just isn't "god does not play dice" and it sets off every kook alarm I have.
[1] http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/microsites/ostp/critique_of_pielke_jr_statements_on_drought.pdf http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/microsites/ost...
- sien 13y agoPielke's response is here: http://rogerpielkejr.blogspot.com.au/2014/03/john-holdrens-epic-fail.html http://rogerpielkejr.blogspot.com.au/2014/03/john-holdrens-e... It was extraordinary that Holdren should write such a harsh attack on an individual scientist, particularly when as pointed out by Pielke that his response is entirely consistent with IPCC SREX. Here is the most important quote in Pielke's article: What the IPCC SREX (2012) says: “There is medium confidence that since the 1950s some regions of the world have experienced a trend to more intense and longer droughts, in particular in southern Europe and West Africa, but in some regions droughts have become less frequent, less intense, or shorter, for example, in central North America and northwestern Australia.” For the US the CCSP (2008)20 says: “droughts have, for the most part, become shorter, less frequent, and cover a smaller portion of the U. S. over the last century.”21 It appears that stating what the IPCC says is now outside the consensus according to Holdren.