5 ms·
It's always amazed me that they used Windows. Why would an ATM ever need a full blown OS like that? The requirements are totally different from a desktop PC.
by mcv 13y ago
It's always amazed me that they used Windows. Why would an ATM ever need a full blown OS like that? The requirements are totally different from a desktop PC.
- simcop2387 13y agoLargely because many of them need to display advertisements these days. I've seen ATMs in gas stations that were displaying ads for the type of stuff you'd find in a gas station/convenience store. The rest I've seen advertising services of the bank they are attached to.
- jrabone 13y agoAssuming the developers had half a clue, they don't. They run Windows XP Embedded which can be stripped back to just the kernel and a serial terminal if necessary. It's not like they take a retail XP CDROM and installed it (of course, in the absence of clue this works too...)
- mnl 13y agoI guess that's because back in the 90s there were no practical alternatives to NT and OS/2, then NT4 won. XP was an obvious migration path for the old NT embedded software.
- RogerL 13y agoI've done that with hardware that got installed in a factory. Why not? You pay a one-time, small license fee, you get years of free support from a major company, I don't have to document all the details of my stripped down kernel and how to recreate it, you can hire anybody off the street to work on it long after I am gone (and I am long gone from that company, but the hardware lives on), they didn't have to pay me to build out a unique OS, the low power computer we had could more than handle XP, there was (and continues to be) continued new, unknown requirements and upgrades, the people required to occasionally touch the interface had more PC experience than for any embedded or linux OS, and on and on. Why wouldn't I slap a copy of XP on there? Well, this story is the counter-argument, of course. I still think it was the right decision.
- _greim_ 13y agoThey took the path of least resistance and it paid off until now. Now that path is a dead end and they face a painful upgrade. But arguably it was still worth it in the long run.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoThis seems the most salient point. At some point someone said "What if XP isn't supported?" and someone else said "Well we'll deal with that when it comes, but for now we've got a product to ship."
- jimbobimbo 13y agoIt is not necessarily a full-blown XP - it might be XP Embedded, which looks like XP, but is highly componentized to reduce requirements to the hardware or improve on security. In either case, I don't understand why ATM industry should be pissed - it's not that they were patching ATMs on a regular basis... In case of XP Embedded the patching story is even more convoluted.