3 ms·
I'm not sure you grasped the parent comment's point. The idea was that there would be a penalty to include charges that could be struck out at a preliminary hea
by graeme 13y ago
I'm not sure you grasped the parent comment's point. The idea was that there would be a penalty to include charges that could be struck out at a preliminary hearing.
As it stands, there is incentive to threaten a defendant with onerous charges that would never stand up in court. Most cases are settled by plea bargains. I'm not clear on the statistics, but I think this means they never reach preliminary.
Under the parent's proposal, the prosecution could not introduce spurious charges without risking losing their actual legitimate charges.
I don't know what the unintended consequences would be, but striking off the charges is not a "bizarre" part of the proposal. It's the point of the proposal.