3 ms·
I'm very sympathetic to this point of view, but the author starts inauspiciously when he asserts that a news anchor should have been prosecuted for using a high
by jessaustin 13y ago
I'm very sympathetic to this point of view, but the author starts inauspiciously when he asserts that a news anchor should have been prosecuted for using a high-capacity gun magazine as a visual aid in his newscast. Perhaps he's had his mind made up about prosecutorial discretion too long to see this episode as an example of discretion done right.
- rossjudson 13y agoExactly. Reynolds deliberately lies about the what the prosecutor said in his first paragraph. The prosecutor did not state that the on-air violation was clear. What he said was that the device "meets the definition" of the statute. Gregory was displaying the "device" during a newscast. bran·dish verb gerund or present participle: brandishing 1. wave or flourish (something, esp. a weapon) as a threat or in anger or excitement. Did he "brandish" the device? No. Reynolds knows that, but he decides to draw a false equivalence anyway.
- mason240 13y agoSo you would be willing to "displaying the device" on a street in a poor DC neighborhood since you are certain that you would be within the law?
- rossjudson 13y agoOf course not. In a public space, without appropriate context? You know this already. Keep looking for some way to find that Reynolds is right. If the law meant to say "display", it would have said "display". The law says "brandish". That has a meaning. Did Gregory brandish the device with anger, or intent to threaten?
- mason240 13y agoWhy would the public setting, or even context matter? If you are only "displaying" and not "brandishing," you'll be fine.
- yuubi 13y agoChasing links from footnote 1 of the paper, one finds that the statute is supposed to prohibit possession, so whether waving it around on air counts as "brandishing" isn't obviously relevant. http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/crime/nbcs-gregory-wont-be-charged-for-displaying-ammunition-clip-on-tv/2013/01/11/984a7bda-5c1d-11e2-beee-6e38f5215402_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/crime/nbcs-gregory-wont-...