3 ms·
The analysis misses the crucial factor - access to credit. A middle-class homeowner can easily borrow tens of thousands of dollars cheaply and easily via credi
by jdietrich 13y ago
The analysis misses the crucial factor - access to credit.
A middle-class homeowner can easily borrow tens of thousands of dollars cheaply and easily via credit cards and overdrafts. With a good credit history, you don't need liquid savings to deal with a temporary cashflow problem; Low interest rates mean that it is economically rational to rely on credit in this way, rather than having capital under-utilised in instant access savings accounts.
Credit is vastly more expensive for the poor, especially the unbanked poor (who represent around 8% of the American population). Borrowing $1000 for a couple of months costs just a few dollars if you have a low-rate credit card, but hundreds if your only access to credit is through payday lending. Without the cushion of cheap credit, it is imperative to have a rainy-day fund.
The availability of peer support is also highly relevant; If you have affluent family and friends, then the consequences of cashflow problems are greatly diminished.
The author draws the conclusion that the middle-classes are financially insecure, but I think that the converse is true - they choose to spend to the limit of their income because they are highly financially secure and do not fear short-term cashflow problems.
- jobu 13y agoThat's a great point. They only looked at the last 25 years, but I bet the story is different in the late 70s and early 80s when interest rates were significantly higher.
- ghaff 13y agoCredit cards aren't necessarily the best example as they carry horrendous interest rates relative to just about everything else in today's market. That said, they can paper over a very short-term cash flow crunch easily without costing too much. And, as you say, there are often many other sources of credit such as family, HELOCs, etc. That said: >they choose to spend to the limit of their income I'd argue that this is generally not a good idea unless "spend to the limit" includes a budget for savings.