5 ms·
My YC Startup Enters Private Beta
What do you think? We're still twiddling with the design, so any notes there would be greatly appreciated.
- kyro 19y agoLike most have said, the design seems very appropriate for this type of site. Signed up for beta as well. I'm curious to see what's inside.
- herdrick 19y agoLove the new silhouette front page. I can smell the Ohio loam. I can only register for a Freeroll within 60 minutes of start time?
- mattmaroon 19y agoYes. Otherwise it would fill up 4 days in advance and nobody would actually play.
- mikesabat 19y agoCool idea - I was definitely looking for this two months back. I'm excited to see the type of stuff that you guys are adding to fantasy sports. Maybe you could add some cool, weekly pickems, at least for football. I don't know anyone that plays basketball or hockey. I'd imagine football is way ahead for fantasy sports, and I don't think people will start fantasy football now.
- JRM 19y agoThe site is based on short season leagues. So playing fantasy football right now is actually exactly what people will be doing :D
- brett 19y ago"register in seconds" and the huge "play free now" button did a really good job of funneling me to the register page that I couldn't use because I don't have an invite code. I realized that I needed to request an invitation only after I had filled out 2/3rds of the registration form.
- mattmaroon 19y agoOh, sorry. That button will have some much more exciting functionality in the near future, but we should fix that for now.
- mattmaroon 19y agoWe're still twiddling with the design, so any notes there would be appreciated.
- cstejerean 19y agoI don't mind the feedback button scrolling, after all it's a beta site and it makes good sense to have the Feedback button jump out at people otherwise they'll never do it.
- nickb 19y agoDesign looks great to me! You've nailed the sports theme! Signed up for beta. PS: Another cool Rails startup!
- mattmaroon 19y agoI'll send you an invite.
- yc_reject 19y agohuh? are u kidding me? u think this design is great? man you really need to get out and see the tubes
- rms 19y agoI like the design a lot. I find the fixed scrolling thing on the left disorienting. You've got a lot of extra room in the bar at the top; can you make the login box, the register link, and/pr the navbar links bigger?
- dartman111 19y agoIt is stolen from Yahoo! Sports? http://sports.yahoo.com/nba http://sports.yahoo.com/nba
- garbowza 19y agoI really like the design and the concept is quite clever. I think there's a definite niche here. However, I too am annoyed by the scrolling feedback bar, and my browser won't let me close it once it's opened.
- mattmaroon 19y agoYou can't hit cancel and close it? What browser/OS do you use?
- garbowza 19y agoWindows XP & Firefox 2. The Cancel button jumps in and out of view, but doesn't stay available long enough to click it. It works fine for me in IE though.
- mattmaroon 19y agoWow, that's unusual. Going to have to check into that. Thanks.
- garbowza 19y agoActually it turns out it only occurs when I change my browser size away from maximized. It never allows me to scroll down far enough to see the buttons...
- brianr 19y agoi like the design a lot. can you make the 'FEEDBACK' link look clickable? (hand cursor)
- mattmaroon 19y agoThanks, we will.
- Alex3917 19y agoI love how you incorporated online poker design idioms into your interface. Did you talk about that in your initial pitch to YC or is that something you decided on later?
- mattmaroon 19y agoYes, we did. We're definitely incorporating a lot of what made online poker so successful.
- muerdeme 19y agoWill I be able to multi-table drafts? What's the official stance on bots? Just kidding. Halfway. This is a great idea and I hope you guys do well. Is there a friendly rivalry with Chris Fargis going on?
- mattmaroon 19y agoYes, you can multi-table. Bots aren't really a worry in this, since you can already set a draft queue, and soon we'll have customizable rankings. We (and all other FS sites) basically have a bot built in for you.
- muriithi 19y agoGood design but I have to keep scrolling to see everything on my poor man's 800*600 res.
- russ 19y agoSorry man...didn't know those existed anymore! jk :P
- daniel-cussen 19y agoAre you the soldiers for fortune guys?
- ced 19y agoI had to look up what a Fantasy Sport was. Perhaps a one-liner in your FAQ could help.
- Tichy 19y agoI looked it up when the first information about the Summer YCs was available. Nevertheless, it seems very difficult to get into, so maybe a tutorial would be called for. I am really not the target audience, though, as I don't care one iota for spectator sports. Although I am interested in game theory and gambling, so who knows.
- mattmaroon 19y agoYou would be surprised how little sports you need to know to compete.
- Tichy 19y agoI suppose I'll be able to find some tutorials somewhere on the web, once I have some spare time. It certainly has several interesting aspects.
- mattmaroon 19y agoI'll definitely work on explaining it to people better. One of my cofounders is absolutely crushing at fantasy football and rarely ever watches a game. It's more than anything looking at statistics and learning how they apply.
- fleaflicker 19y agois the request invite feature broken?
- JRM 19y agoI dont think it is. What problem did you have?
- fleaflicker 19y agoit's working now, wasn't earlier
- yc_reject 19y agoso my constructive criticism was not accepted by the YC moderators .. they decided to take away my feedback .. so I better start saying ONLY GOOD THINGS here. _Start_Sucking_Up_ WOW.. Matt your app is the most revolutionary web 2.0 and profit machine that I've seen.. The design is so awesome that you can just live by it. I'm sure all your users would be WOW by this awesome design. They will return every 5 mins to this awesome site just to take another look at this cool, nice, awesome, sweet design. Best YC's pick so far. _End_Sucking_Up ok happy YC moderator.
- Caligula 19y agoA lot of the sports leagues demand royalty from fantasy sports leagues. There have even been lawsuits over this as they believe it to be proprietary data. Are you guys paying them royalty? Real good concept. Add a real money feature and i'd play.
- JRM 19y agoThere is a recent case against the MLB which says that the data is public domain. The MLB has already lost an appeal on this matter as well (see http://www.draftmix.com/news/index.php/2007/10/17/draftmix-news/cbc-vs-mlb/ http://www.draftmix.com/news/index.php/2007/10/17/draftmix-n...) for details
- Caligula 19y agoGood to hear. another note , in your about us you say "We're currently the only site offering live drafts all day every day throughout each sport's season. We offer short term, hands off leagues, so you won't be penalized if you can't login five times a day to manage teams. And we offer guaranteed cash prizes with a simple, easy to understand structure" A quick google search showed https://www.fantasysportslive.com https://www.fantasysportslive.com Im sure there are other sites. I think your game lobby is better than yours. I look forward to trying it when other players are on and its real $. cheers.
- mattmaroon 19y agoFSL doesn't do live drafts. They do some goofy version of salary cap pick'ems.
- r7000 19y agoI like the preseason 'beta' label. Very waggish.
- yc_reject 19y agowhat! it's so typical web 2.0ish crap.. and u think it's nice?
- utnick 19y agocool design Have you consulted with a lawyer about the legality of running a league with an entry fee and a prize pool? I have a feeling that is not legal in all 50 states.
- JRM 19y agoYes we have. It is legal in most states. We will post this info in our terms of service once the lawyers finish them up. States where it is not legal are still able to play in free games.
- mattmaroon 19y agoYeah, we are going to operate in 39.
- goofygrin 19y agoRequest Invite requires a name with a space in it? I just put my first name in and got a generic error message. It looks like you're using Flex? How'd that work for you?
- russ 19y agoHm..I put in a name without a space and it worked fine..? What error msg did you get?
- mattmaroon 19y agoFlex is pretty awesome. We use it for the draft and lobby. The lobby we probably could get away with AJAX for in the future, but I'd dread using that for the draft.
- yc_reject 19y agoi know i'm getting flamed for this but holy cow, this is the type of crap that YC funds? man ... this is so bs.
- yc_reject 19y agoman... a lot of "sucking up" to the YC winner .. nice design , cool design, great design.. man .. i don't find the design great .. it's just average.
- rms 19y agoCare to show us your startup?
- rms 19y agoCertainly they fund some sites that don't go anywhere, but this site has a very clear potential for profit. It's the best one I've seen come out of YC in a while.
- Mistone 19y agocongrats on the launch - maybe its just me - but it took me a while to figure out what the site does - I don't think that info belongs in the FAQ section. Design is clean - well done. Again I'm not a big Fantasy player or online gamer but there are terms and language on the site (Draft lobby) that I simply did not know what they are referring to. a short demo video, or "new to fantasy sports?" tab would be helpful. I guess I felt like I wanted to use the site but did not know what to do.