7 ms·
I find that in engineering circles theology and the notion of the existence of God is one of those 'moral taboos.' And advocating more nuclear power stations or
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
I find that in engineering circles theology and the notion of the existence of God is one of those 'moral taboos.' And advocating more nuclear power stations or private gun ownership.
It is fascinating that were you to advocate gun control in the late 19th century, it seems nearly everyone would have laughed you out of the room. But that sentiment has reversed here in the 21st century.
Always interesting to think about.
- mattgreenrocks 13y agoHere's another one that will incite HN: Personal ambition is overrated, and we're actually just buying into the lies of Western culture that we have to become the Ubermensch to be happy. I struggle with this.
- paulbaumgart 13y agoPersonal ambition can be redirected into an ambition to improve the world around you, which is pretty healthy and utility-promoting on balance.
- marvin 13y agoYes! I love the heresy :D I wish there were more frank expressions of beliefs that go against the status quo. I strongly agree with you, even as my core moral values and ambitions line very well up with the chase of my personal ambitions.
- eli_gottlieb 13y ago>Personal ambition is overrated, and we're actually just buying into the lies of Western culture that we have to become the Ubermensch to be happy. Completely agreed. In actual fact, most such people aren't even real ubermenschen. They have no mission, no true values of their own that they will impose on the world. Their ambitions are not only the small beer of rising in wealth but the zero-sum nonsense of rising in social status. Their dreams are forever confined to the cage of the established capitalist system. What's another dollar? Many so-called ambitious professionals are just more self-deceiving pigs in human clothing. </grimdark>
- cadlin 13y agoThere was plenty of gun control enacted in the late 19th and early 20th century. It was targeted toward black southerners, however, and AFAIK rarely made it to the US Supreme Court. The laws were usually ruled more-or-less constitutional. Here are 5 decisions: http://www.constitution.org/2ll/2ndcourt/state/18st.htm http://www.constitution.org/2ll/2ndcourt/state/18st.htm http://www.constitution.org/2ll/2ndcourt/state/23st.htm http://www.constitution.org/2ll/2ndcourt/state/23st.htm http://tennesseeencyclopedia.net/entry.php?rec=25 http://tennesseeencyclopedia.net/entry.php?rec=25 http://www.constitution.org/2ll/2ndcourt/state/154st.htm http://www.constitution.org/2ll/2ndcourt/state/154st.htm http://www.guncite.com/court/state/31ar455.html http://www.guncite.com/court/state/31ar455.html
- defen 13y agoRe: gun control, depends where you live. I grew up in a rural area where you'd still be laughed out of the room for suggesting that gun control was a good idea.
- morganherlocker 13y agoThis is very true. My state just passed a law with overwhelming support that allows people to have guns in bars again. I did not expect it to be controversial to believe that drinking + guns + crowded rooms was a bad idea, but apparently I was wrong.
- avar 13y agoFrom the perspective of someone living in mainland Europe the legislation around bars in the U.S. is quite baffling. I was over in San Francisco last summer and walked out of a bar pint in hand to tag along for a cigarette break, we were promptly chastised about it. I apologized saying that I'd briefly forgotten what continent I was on. It's also not unusual to see children milling around with their parents in bars in Europe well into the evening. There's no demand that you have to be of drinking age to be in the establishment, just that you can't be sold drinks if that's not the case. All in all it contributes to a more relaxed atmosphere around drinking and I suspect to overall moderation and safety around drinking. If you ban guns in bars then someone who carries a gun around anyway will have to stash it somewhere before they arrive, or risk breaking the law. I carry a swiss army knife on my keychain because it's a useful tool, I bring that to bars I go to. I don't think I'm any more likely to attempt to stab someone after a few pints than I otherwise would.
- r00fus 13y ago> If you ban guns in bars then someone who carries a gun around anyway will have to stash it somewhere before they arrive, or risk breaking the law. Coat check for guns? A peace tie (zip-tie) on the holster? It's not like this isn't a well understood problem.
- 13y ago
- waps 13y agoExactly. Even in Paul Graham's own essay, some things are always forgotten. He's smart enough to question why the Church/Italian state attacked Galileo for repeating Copernicus' ideas, who was a celebrated hero of the church. And nobody ever realizes that Galileo was not at all interested in the scientific facts (well he was, up to the point he went insane and became a political agitator and generally a lunatic, read his letters, you'll see that I'm actually quite polite here). Rather he was organizing demonstrations and violence because the church owed him a different kind of state (needless to say, with him on top) because the earth rotated around the sun (amongst many other "reasons", most of them quite insane). This case was then dug up later to justify ripping the catholic church out of Germany. That failed, but the story about Galileo stuck. Some of our historical heroes ... aren't heroes. Socrates is a similar situation. Celebrated philosopher. Speaker at nearly every forum (meaning the weekly meeting where their direct democracy happened). He was an advocate, a statesman, a philosopher. And then they execute him. Wait. What ? Nobody ever seems to think that they've probably skipped over small part of the story here. An inaccurate summary was that Socrates' students were involved TWICE with actions that led to the military sacking of Athens, with very strong suspicions of him having ordered them to do so. This "just happened" to occur right after one of the first times he didn't get his way in the forum. The first time he got off with a stern warning, execution of every one of his students involved that sided with the occupying force, and a promise not to have any students for 2 years, which he promptly ignored. Then it very nearly happened again, and again his students were helping the enemy army. Then he was executed together with his students. There is at least a decent case to be made that Galileo was executed for organizing violent protests against the state (using, amongst many other things, the idea that the earth rotated around the sun as a rallying idea). Likewise, Socrates was likely killed for organizing the military conquest of Athens when he couldn't democratically get his way in parliament twice (and for having a habit of sleeping with the wives of other Atheneans). Not because Atheneans were afraid of science. Neither of them were very nice people. Not that horrible people can't be important forces of good in history, but you should at least note that this is so. E.g. Kemal Ataturk, an early 20th century figure that a lot more genocidal than Hitler. He also ended the 1.5 millenia long war of muslims against the west and the east, and frankly without him we would not have a modern time. He ended it because he thought it was a waste of money, effort and most of all, lives, not because he was against war. He just didn't believe the objective was worth the cost. Still, his importance in making our current mostly democratic world possible is at least on par with Churchill. But he is a monster, personally responsible for several ethnic extermination campaigns, no doubt about that.
- chippy 13y agoReally? I find that philosophy and the God question, faith etc is really the opposite to a taboo - it's what we mostly seem to end up discussing in the pub after the tech talk has died down. But we are British techs, which may make a difference. It's all logic at the end of the day - or at least that's the path we take in talking about it.
- cjslep 13y agoI'm surprised at the mentioning of nuclear power plants. As an insider looking out, is it really that taboo to discuss? As an aside, I feel like the few conversations I've seen on HN surrounding it are well-informed and generally a technical discussion compared to the degenerate mud-slinging that can occur when discussing other topics. Then again, I'm only exposed to the "Nuclear Power Policy" dialogue occurring in the United States. Edited for clarity.
- ggreer 13y agoPolitics is the mindkiller and all that.[1] For almost every X where you can say, "Were you to advocate X in the late 19th century, it seems nearly everyone would have laughed you out of the room. But that sentiment has reversed here in the 21st century.", it is a good thing that opinions on X have changed. This heuristic isn't perfect, but it should cause you to think more about X. 1. http://lesswrong.com/lw/gw/politics_is_the_mindkiller/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/gw/politics_is_the_mindkiller/
- GeneralMayhem 13y agoIt's a good thing from the point of view of the present. We may decide in another two hundred years that it was better the old way after all.
- mattchew 13y agoFunny you should say this. Just the other day I was telling a friend of mine that I really should have been born in the 19th century. Much of what people believed then makes more sense to me than what people think today.
- JackFr 13y agoForget God -- a belief in any transcendent property or existence or even a rejection of pure reductionism is typically greeted with a scowl and an argument which boils down to "Come on. . . . you really don't believe that."
- davidtanner 13y agoThat's the real thing you can't (respectably) say - not the trope of "God isn't real"
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoI'm fairly sure there are professional philosophers who reject strong reductionism as a form of scientism. Don't ask me why, as I'm not trained in philosophy, and I'm told that computer people make utter dorks of ourselves when we try to talk about philosophy without training.
- declan 13y ago>It is fascinating that were you to advocate gun control in the late 19th century, it seems nearly everyone would have laughed you out of the room. You're right in general, though as <cadlin> points out modern forms of "gun control" do have late 19th century racist roots. But outright criminal prohibitions on personal possession of firearms -- which we had in the U.S. in some areas before the Supreme Court's Heller decision -- would have been unthinkable. So would effectively complete bans on carrying weapons both concealed or openly, which some areas still have until the Supreme Court rules in the next 2A case up for arguments this fall. > But that sentiment has reversed here in the 21st century. It depends on who you talk to. If you were in a room filled with libertarian-minded engineers at Google or Microsoft, and there are plenty of them, you'd be the one laughed out of the room. Or if you were in a diner in most rural areas of the United States. But in certain coastal enclaves, yes, "gun control" has come to have a religious import. Though the taboo-to-question topic I thought of first when reading pg's 2004 essay (a well written one, too) was anthropogenic global warming.
- afterburner 13y agoIsn't it anti-gun-control that takes on a religious import? "From my cold dead hands" and all that?
- declan 13y agoNot in the same way. I know the chairman of the Calguns Foundation (hoffmang on Twitter), who's also for HN purposes the chairman and CEO of a ~200-employee Silicon Valley recurring billing/subscription management startup. My understanding of his position, and I may of course have it wrong or be misremembering, is that he's okay with some form of background checks, perhaps via proof of backgroundcheckness, for ownership as long as you can actually own the firearm you want. He's okay with regulations on open or concealed carry as long as you can have some form of reasonable carry. This is the opposite of the extreme near-religious positions of folks who want to ban guns. See Democrat Sen. Dianne Feinstein (CA) telling 60 Minutes she wanted an "outright ban" on all guns -- "Mr. and Mrs. America turn 'em all in" -- but didn't have enough Senate votes for it. http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2013/01/01/Reminder-Sen-Feinstein-Said-She-Wants-All-Guns-Banned http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2013/01/01/Reminder-...
- wmil 13y agoI think that's a separate issue. As a general social rule you aren't supposed to bring up religion or politics at a general social gathering since people have strong opinions driven by their group affiliations. It hijacks conversations, starts fights, and doesn't accomplish anything since people will be arguing from an emotional reaction. That doesn't mean you can't ever discuss politics and religion, just be understanding if other people aren't interested in your views.
- mikeash 13y agoDiscussing God is a completely practical taboo, though. Most people, perhaps all people, don't arrive at their opinion on religion through rational thought. I make this claim due to the obvious fact that there are a lot of contradictory religious beliefs out there, and if most people used rational thought then you'd expect most people to have similar beliefs. They don't, thus most people aren't rational about it. Since most, perhaps all, people are irrational about it, there's no point in discussing it. It's just going to cause anger and pain. Better to avoid it.
- joshuacc 13y ago> if most people used rational thought then you'd expect most people to have similar beliefs Well, possibly. But then again, what if all those people happen to have very different sets of evidence on which to make their decisions?
- mikeash 13y agoThat would explain the disparity in the past, but I don't think it's an adequate explanation any longer.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoSome folks do arrive at their opinions rationally, just sayin' :-)
- mikeash 13y agoSure, but far from a majority.
- JoshTriplett 13y agoAnd it's sad that the statement you just made is often far more taboo than the topic itself.
- bradleysmith 13y agoI've noticed this as well regarding theology and private gun ownership. To begin a discussion about religion with any attitude other than critical seems to incite a very negative response among most engineers (and tangentially, people who strongly identify with "internet culture"). An assumption of 'rightness' is very strong on these issues, from both sides. I have NOT noticed this at all with regards to nuclear power stations. I've found that there is a fairly even divide among 'reductionist' or science-praising mindsets about nuclear being net negative or net positive. just my two anecdotal cents.
- sliverstorm 13y agoHah, theology/nuclear power/gun ownership, is that so? I'm 3 for 3, some engineer I make.
- johngalt 13y agoTheology maybe. I find it difficult to believe that there are engineers against gun ownership and impossible that there are engineers against nuclear power, to the degree that both subjects are taboo. Gun ownership is just fear of a tool. I'd see it in a similar vein as ignorant people thinking that TV rots your brain. Or fearing the RTGs on Cassini/MSL. Any engineer should be able to easily identify that breathless tone people use when they blame the tool for human failings. Nuclear power stations? An engineering circle where nuclear power is encouraged is more likely. I've got a hard time imagining engineers sitting around reasonably coming to the conclusion that carbon free power in huge quantities is taboo to even discuss.
- marvin 13y agoGreat point. I'm a Christian and also a scientist. I am very reluctant to share my religious beliefs with peers. And I keep my mouth firmly shut whenever someone cites Dawkins, Harris et.al. on the part of their writings that assesses the general intellectual competency of religious people and (peaceful) religious communities. A couple of times I've tried the philosophical argument, but I get shot down every time. It's easier to just stuff it.
- testacular 13y agoI have a couple colleagues who are openly Christian, and will mention church events when asked what they're doing this weekend. Nobody cares. I go shooting sometimes, and I sometimes talk about guns with another colleague. Nobody cares. I've suggested that thorium reactors might be a great idea during lunch conversations, and nobody batted an eye. These aren't terribly taboo taboos.
- nkurz 13y agoTestacular: You were banned a week ago. testacular 42 minutes ago | link | parent [dead] | on: What You Can't Say (2004) I have a couple colleagues who are openly Christian, and will mention church events when asked what they're doing this weekend. Nobody cares. I go shooting sometimes, and I sometimes talk about guns with another colleague. Nobody cares. I've suggested that thorium reactors might be a great idea during lunch conversations, and nobody batted an eye. These aren't terribly taboo taboos.