(a-priori: for some reason I can't reply directly to you) It's not quite a "no true Scotsman" since great ideas do happen and happen fairly often, in the grand

(a-priori: for some reason I can't reply directly to you) It's not quite a "no true Scotsman" since great ideas do happen and happen fairly often, in the grand scheme of things (there are over 100 Nobel prize nominees every year). The oft-repeated argument about ideas versus execution is that ideas are a dime a dozen, which is true, but most of them are not really all that great or original. The same can be said for any resource.