3 ms·
These are well-done graphics and Reuters Graphics has an excellent stylebook...but just to be a nag...this strikes me as a good example of how custom Web naviga
by danso 13y ago
These are well-done graphics and Reuters Graphics has an excellent stylebook...but just to be a nag...this strikes me as a good example of how custom Web navigation can be counterproductive for the reader.
I'm sure most people can figure out that the top three images are meant to be buttons, but I'll admit that I didn't notice, at first, that when you click each subhed-button, a "Next" option pops up in the top right, along with page-boxes to the top left. It's obvious once you've noticed them, but the trick is noticing them in the first place, which you might not because your eyes immediately jump down to the graphic. How many users, after seeing the initial graphic, immediately click on one of the other subhead buttons, thus seeing only a total of 3 graphics?
An equally problematic issue is that there's no way to deep-link any of the items. I can't easily discuss a specific graphic (and they're hard to locate via rightclicking, as they're embedded via svg tag) here, or even one of the subnav-topics, without fully describing the actual graphic...which is a real inconvenience. The use of clickable gray boxes as pagination only adds to the inconvenience, because now I have to count which box I'm on.
I think this would've been better served by having each sub-topic be a long, scrollable webpage...as it is now, you already have to scroll to read most of these graphics. Once you get done with one graphic, you have to scroll back to the top, click "Next", and then read through...at least have a "Next" at the bottom.
The main argument for having this compact nav is to invite quicker comparison between slides...I don't think that's a great argument even in the best of cases, but here, because of the vertically-long slides, it's not even applicable. It'd be far easier to flip back between sequential graphics by simply scrolling.
OK, that was a lot of nagging, but I hate to see great work obfuscated by "gee-whiz" navigational design that is user-unfriendly. I would discuss the graphics but like I said, it's kind of a pain to specify and describe each particular slide without deeplinks.