4 ms·
I prefer option 3 - ISPs charge more for people that use more. I know this would require marketing changes, and many customers wouldn't like it, so it won't hap
by Nursie 13y ago
I prefer option 3 - ISPs charge more for people that use more. I know this would require marketing changes, and many customers wouldn't like it, so it won't happen and instead they'll just keep doing what they're doing and trying to extort money from data-heavy services.
Option 1 is unfair to some people, Option 2 puts a huge barrier to entry in place for businesses. Option 3 is the only real solution IMHO.
- ataggart 13y agoThe problem with option 3 is people don't really want to pay for what they consume, and the state is happy to oblige by placing itself as the middle-man between concentrated benefits and dispersed costs.
- exelius 13y agoOption 3 is data caps and/or metered billing. It's not exactly the most consumer-friendly option, but the ISPs would love to do it that way if they could.
- pessimizer 13y agoI love metered billing. The problem with it is that the video streamers will discover how much more bandwidth than everyone else they're using, and AT&T and Comcast's all-you-can-eat video services that use the same wire will look a lot more attractive to them. Ultimately, that may be a threat to network neutrality as the prices are raised on the metered internet in order to shift bandwidth to those siloed TV services, and the public won't care because they're not streaming video over the open internet anymore.
- exelius 13y agoWell, the reason it works for all-you-can-eat video services is that the cable companies are providing a distribution service to the content owners. So for HBO, they provide both cable distribution and caching of video for HBO Go. They could pretty easily do the same for Netflix; considering Netflix is basically HBO that's sold outside the cable companies at this point. HBO does in effect pay the cable companies for distribution in that the cable companies take a percentage of the monthly HBO subscription fee that the customer pays, so I don't see why Netflix shouldn't. I think a lot of geeks are in love with net neutrality because they see it as a fairness thing and think it will keep the cable companies from gouging them. In reality, it's just about cost allocation. Companies are going to take their profits under net neutrality or not; and the profit margins on cable aren't astronomically high. Netflix would never have gotten off the ground under true network neutrality; the costs have to be allocated somewhere. If you want pure speed though; metered billing is the way to go. Look at how fast mobile data has become in the US relative to the rest of the world -- a large part of that is because it's profitable for Verizon and AT&T to have customers use more data. Businesses are going to make their profits and regulation isn't going to have much effect on the prices that consumers pay -- but under the right rules, if you create a situation where companies can make more money by providing a better service, everyone wins.