3 ms·
Modern thinking is to take out a carrier with a nuke: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21#DF-21D_.28CSS-5_Mod-4.29_Anti-ship_ballistic_missile http://en.wikipedi
by gaius 13y ago
Modern thinking is to take out a carrier with a nuke: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21#DF-21D_.28CSS-5_Mod-4.29_Anti-ship_ballistic_missile http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21#DF-21D_.28CSS-5_Mod-4.29_...
"United States Naval Institute in 2009 stated that such a warhead would be large enough to destroy an aircraft carrier in one hit and that there was "currently ... no defense against it" if it worked as theorized."
- hga 13y agoYou left out our response to this development further in the article: "The United States Navy has responded by switching its focus from a close blockade force of shallow water vessels to return to building deep water ballistic defense destroyers. The United States has also assigned most of its ballistic missile defense capable ships to the Pacific, extended the BMD program to all Aegis destroyers and increased procurement of SM-3 BMD missiles. The United States also has a large network optimized for tracking ballistic missile launches which may give carrier groups sufficient warning in order to move away from the target area while the missile is in flight." We've been playing the BMD (Ballistic Missile Defense) game longer than the PRC has been playing the ICBM game.... ADDED: we've got 62 Arleigh Burke class destroyers operating, 8 on order and another 6 planned.
- kjs3 13y agoYes, but escalation from "attack a US aircraft carrier" to "nuke a US aircraft carrier" isn't linear. It represents a decision on the part of the attacker to absorb a nuclear response from the US.
- gaius 13y agoYou're using Cold War logic in a world of martyrdom.
- dragonwriter 13y agoThe concept of noble martyrdom has been a tool used by the powerful to motivate footsoldiers since the dawn of time -- its not something new, or something that didn't exist during the Cold War.
- gaius 13y agoLet's consider another scenario, the leadership of a country like Iran or North Korea successfully nukes a US aircraft carrier. Would the US respond by nuking a city full of civilians? Maybe... but maybe not.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Let's consider another scenario, the leadership of a country like Iran or North Korea successfully nukes a US aircraft carrier. Would the US respond by nuking a city full of civilians? Maybe not -- if the leadership of the US thought they had a more effective way of both dealing with those directly responsible for the attack and convincing the public that a sufficient response had been made. Of course, that probably wouldn't be any better for the leadership behind the attack than a nuclear strike that had greater collateral damage.
- kjs3 13y agoNuke a city? Perhaps not (although I'd get the fuck out of Tehran or Pongyang quick, just in case). Nuke every military base in the country? Much more likely. But more importantly, we would be able to do just about anything short of a chemical or biological attack, for as long as we wanted, under the guise of "restrained response to a nuclear attack".
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Nuke a city? Perhaps not (although I'd get the fuck out of Tehran or Pongyang quick, just in case). Nuke every military base in the country? Much more likely. The latter would probably involve several instances of the former.
- kjs3 13y agoWhich is "collateral damage", not "nuking a city", in the propaganda game.
- MrZongle2 13y ago