4 ms·
In relative terms I'm pretty sure we have as much democracy in the UK as we've ever had - after all we have Scotland contemplating leaving the UK and it's being
by arethuza 13y ago
In relative terms I'm pretty sure we have as much democracy in the UK as we've ever had - after all we have Scotland contemplating leaving the UK and it's being done in a reasonably civilized manner and it will ultimately be decided by a vote.
If a large chunk of a country can leave the country based purely on a vote then I'd say we do have democracy in the UK. It might not be perfect, and we have a lot of problems but to say we don't have democracy at all is just plain silly.
- mapleoin 13y agoJust because things can happen based on a vote, it doesn't mean it's a democracy. Or to rephrase your comment: If a large chunk of a country (like Crimea) can leave the country based purely on a vote then I'd say we do have democracy in Ukraine.
- arethuza 13y agoThe difference being that the Westminster parliament complied with the wishes of the parliament in Edinburgh to have a referendum - which is hardly the case with the Ukraine and Crimea. As far as I've noticed, guns and deaths have been absent from the debate around Scottish independence.
- mercurial 13y agoOn the other hand, this was this Irish guy called Michael Collins, back in the day...
- arethuza 13y agoThat was almost a century ago, I might as well mention that there was this Scots guy called William Wallace - I don't think either are particularly relevant to the status of democracy in the UK today. Mind you, mentioning that there is an Irish guy called Gerry Adams might be - but that's getting a bit off topic.
- mercurial 13y agoThis was a bit tongue in cheek, but I do have a point. AFAIK, the UK political system hasn't changed significantly since, people have. There is nothing intrinsic to democracy when it comes to peaceful secession. Or peaceful anything, really.
- tehwalrus 13y agoIndeed, a system with this many contradictions, and this much incompetence, smacks very much of mob rule, aka "democracy". (in case I sound like I'd prefer an elitist administration instead, I should say that I wouldn't have it any other way. least worst, and all that.)