6 ms·
A: We've created a decentralized accounting system and currency that obviates the need for most of the standard accounting controls and fraud prevention measure
by SilasX 13y ago
A: We've created a decentralized accounting system and currency that obviates the need for most of the standard accounting controls and fraud prevention measures, so long as you operate within that currency!
B: Oh yeah? Well look at all the shenanigans that happen at the re-entry points to the conventional financial system! Checkmate, hard-moneyists.
- JulianMorrison 13y agoWhat makes you think it's only exchange providers that are incompetent and/or crooked? Exchange providers tend to hold the largest balances, that makes them targets, but anyone else with a big sack of bitcoins and security by "my cousin knows Linux" is vulnerable too.
- AJ007 13y agoThe analogy I give people is you lock the doors of your house, but it isn't really secure. Anyone can kick down the door or break a window, very easily and very quickly. Your real security for your house comes from the environment which makes it difficult for people to run around ransacking neighborhoods, e.g. your local police force. With bitcoin, you actually have to use real security to secure your possessions. There is no local police force preventing a break in or a credit card company which will absorb fraudulent charges, or a bank that will flag and freeze questionable withdraws. In a crypto currency world, the wealth will have a tendency to flow not to the most business savy or politically connected but to the most secure (in some dimensions we see that the same thing happens with global wealth, both in terms of countries and currencies.) The flip side of that is, stolen bitcoins may fall under a legal classification of stolen property and be retrievable through legal systems -- or at the least blacklisted and non spendable through sources that fall under those jurisdictions. That outcome, I think, is the most important thing to watch, above any other hypothetical bitcoin regulation or banning. If I was an active bitcoin startup I would build a system to identify and classify bitcoins as safe, stolen, unknown, or questionable. Think of the current implementation of bitcoin as crypto currency alpha build 2 or 3. It is slightly amusing that people would risk so much of their own capital to participate in an alpha test, but also necessary in order to truly stress test the system.
- wdewind 13y ago> A: We've created a decentralized accounting system and currency that obviates the need for most of the standard accounting controls and fraud prevention measures, so long as you operate within that currency! I hear this a lot, but I think it's really only true with a massive asterix next to it. Can you explain how bitcoin will work, for instance, in a retail model? It seems like the transactions take a long (relatively) time to verify, which leaves two options: 1. The customer waits (not really a possibility - maybe for bar tabs it's sort of ok?) 2. The vendor purchases some level of security or risk management that allows transactions to occur instantly with a minimum amount of doublespend. And there's your transaction fee. Maybe it will be less than the credit card fee? Am I wrong? I haven't been able to have anyone explain this to me.
- dscrd 13y agoPerhaps you are not aware that actually settling credit card payments, i.e. the time it takes for the money to actually end up in the merchant's bank account may take several days, even weeks. As for bitcoin, to my knowledge this is pretty much analoguous to "transaction confirmation", which typically happens in 10 minutes. So it's actually much much faster than credit card payments.
- wavefunction 13y agoYou just hand-waved away the fact that the trust necessary for an independent retailer to accept an "untrusted" credit-card has been aggregated in Visa and MasterCard and codified through tort law and agreements with the aforementioned credit-card companies. What are you going to do, provide a detailed transaction history to the retailer proving that "your bitcoin transactions always are legit?" Kind of removes the last of the "anonymity" afforded by Bitcoin.
- dcosson 13y agoIt's normally a matter of seconds until other clients can see a bitcoin transaction that you've posted for the network. The only way that will end up not being legit is if you've double-spent the funds - that won't happen if you're a legit user using a regular client, and for the most part even for a nefarious user it would require significant computing resources (e.g. you've already mined a block spending those coins but won't release it until you walk out of the store). So the idea is that if you're a regular retail store, accepting unconfirmed transactions is fine. Unless a big exploit becomes known, any fraud you might happen to see certianly won't any higher than the credit card chargebacks you're getting now. If you're selling your house, you probably want to wait for a few block confirmations. Not to mention there are other crypto-currencies with significantly faster block clearing times, and cryptocoin to cryptocoin exchanges are significantly easier to run than bitcoin to fiat exchanges. So it really seems like all of this is only a minor inconvenience for bitcoin if anything. And there's certainly no reason to ever have to trust someone because "they've been legit in the past", that's an approximation of trust that previous systems have had to rely on but exactly what bitcoin avoids.
- forgottenpass 13y agoA's premise is faulty. The accounting/fraud measures are not obviated. You have slow cash with a transaction log, that's it. shenanigans that happen at the re-entry points to the conventional financial system Those shenanigans aren't exclusive to exchanges. Exchanges are currently the epicenter of shenanigans because they're just high volume and operate on bitcoin as if it wasn't just a different asset in the conventional financial system. People that are neither true believers nor in a specifically bitcoin focused business operate as normal. Bitcoin is just internet fun bucks that have to be liquidated. So the Bitcoin transactions get treated the same as any other transaction, as a result they carry the benefits of the processes created around conventional transactions.
- skywhopper 13y agoTell me again how either of these arguments help the folks who lost their money to MtGox's sloppiness? How is the MtGox debacle (or the other recent BitCoin exchange failures) an example of the lack of need for "standard accounting controls" or "fraud prevention measures"? They are the opposite.