6 ms·
>This is why there is regulation of the finance sector This is why there are bailouts of the finance sector. A bank loses this kind of money, they get it back
by wyager 13y ago
>This is why there is regulation of the finance sector
This is why there are bailouts of the finance sector. A bank loses this kind of money, they get it back for free.
- etherael 13y agoSilence infidel, pro state circle jerk in progress.
- glesica 13y agoJust because the regulation and political system failed doesn't mean they must fail. Iceland did pretty well for itself in the aftermath, even having let the bad behavior slip past them. And Canada apparently never let the bad behavior begin in the first place. Another thing to keep in mind, the people who got the bailouts are a subset of the people who claim unfettered capitalism will cure all ills.
- mseebach 13y agoJust because MtGox failed doesn't mean unregulated Bitcoin businesses must fail. Iceland is a pretty poor posterboy for your point: their banks failed even more spectacularly than other countries', their cleanup effort was just much more ruthless. Essentially your argument in favour of regulation is that we now sort-of know how to clean up after it fails spectacularly. Indeed, other exchanges and other Bitcoin businesses don't appear to suffer from the gross incompetence that brought down MtGox. > Another thing to keep in mind, the people who got the bailouts are a subset of the people who claim unfettered capitalism will cure all ills. Is that so? In that case they are paying the same kind of lip service to that point as a kleptocratic dictator on his private jet is to socialism.
- hnnewguy 13y ago>Iceland did pretty well for itself in the aftermath, even having let the bad behavior slip past them. And Canada apparently never let the bad behavior begin in the first place. Iceland did it by stiffing creditors. That's a short-run gain, long-term pain solution. With regards to Canada, there are specific laws that have inhibited a housing crisis, but we don't know if we have avoided anything yet. Our housing in major centres is as frothy as the peaks of almost anywhere else in the world who suffered a bust. It's too early to say.
- jacalata 13y agoSure, in America. Just because you guys are bad at regulating banks doesn't mean it's impossible.
- smcl 13y agoThe now-defunct FSA in the UK was pretty bad at regulating our banks too, mind.
- claudius 13y ago> A bank loses this kind of money, they get it back for free. Customers lose that kind of money, they get it back for free. Socialising losses is an annoyingly common theme in ‘capitalist’ countries; unfortunately, it is politically infeasible not to bail out failed banks.
- shpxnvz 13y agoLet's not forget that in neither case is it 'free'. The public foots the bill in both cases.
- yardie 13y agoWhat do the bailouts have to do with the regulation of banks? In the US, banks are regulated by the Federal Reserve. They have the authority to close and liquidate a bank. They have no authority to bailout a bank. That authority is the responsibility of Congress. I'm pretty sure it's the same in other countries with a regulated banking sector. The UK parliament decided to bailout their banks, the German senate chose not to.
- icebraining 13y agoIn the US, banks are regulated by the Federal Reserve. That's way too simple a statement for the US banking system. Banks in the US are regulated by the Federal Reserve, by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, by the Office of Foreign Assets Control and a few others.
- yardie 13y ago"Banks" is a catchall for a place to deposit or get money. Not all banks are under the regulations of FDIC, like GS, but all banks are under the regulations of the Reserve.
- maxerickson 13y agoI'm not sure you mean otherwise, but part of the bailout process in 2008 was to allow Goldman Sachs and Merrill Lynch (now part of Bank of America) to become bank holding companies. The major reason was so they could shore up their balance sheets with cheap and safe FDIC insured accounts.
- hnnewguy 13y ago>so they could shore up their balance sheets with cheap and safe FDIC insured accounts. FDIC insured accounts are liabilities on a bank's balance sheet.
- maxerickson 13y ago
- simonh 13y agoExcept that taken as a whole, the bailout money was already been paid back in full, with interest over 2 years ago. But that doesn't stop this old sore being rolled out regularly. Who need the truth when you've got Truthiness on your side, eh? http://www.politifact.com/new-hampshire/statements/2012/oct/25/barack-obama/barack-obama-says-banks-paid-back-all-federal-bail/ http://www.politifact.com/new-hampshire/statements/2012/oct/...
- work_account_2 13y agoPaying it back is great and all, but it shouldn't have had to be done in the first place.
- Mikeb85 13y agoIt shouldn't have. But the pain the economy would have felt would have been 10X worse. Banks supply capital to firms, the government bailed them out (and the automakers) because no one else was willing to supply capital to get the economy rolling.
- gaius 13y agoSure. When are the automakers going to pay back their bailouts?
- pcrh 13y agoThe banks may have paid back the cash they borrowed, but the negative impact of their behavior and the 2008 crisis is still being felt (and paid for) around the world.
- serf 13y agosympathy for the devil. as already stated, the economic impacts were larger than the money owed, and the abstract impacts are untold and likely substantial. the 'too big to fail' paradigm was novel, and a clear abuse of their position. Most of us are upset at the fact that corporations literally held the idea of 'global financial well-being' hostage. "Save us, if not only to save yourselves." is not anything that any corporation should ever or ever be able to say, especially to the government of an entire nation.