3 ms·
Actually no, in fact it's counterproductive. That's a mindless aphorism thrown about to deflect blame from the actual people responsible for decisions, similar
by mindslight 13y ago
Actually no, in fact it's counterproductive. That's a mindless aphorism thrown about to deflect blame from the actual people responsible for decisions, similar to "companies are legally required to maximize profit".
- toomuchtodo 13y agoI get your perspective (after checking your profile). Is Louis CK counterproductive because he doesn't grab a pitchfork and head to Congress to reform copyright law? No. He sells his videos for $5 and asks you nicely not to copy them. Some people try to fix the system. Some people try to do good within the system. Some people do both. Don't shit on someone's parade because you don't feel they didn't do enough, otherwise you alienate your allies.
- mindslight 13y agoIt seems like you're mixing another comment of mine with what I wrote above. For what it's worth, I like Louis CK's approach - it looks like a great post-copyright business model. But your original comment is orthogonal to working within the system. Saying that companies have to "protect their trademarks or lose them" is indeed true in the strict legal sense. But a company could legally "protect" their trademark by issuing yearly licenses for token compensation for products that they consider different enough, but the law might not. By taking the strict legal definition out of its narrow context, you imply that a company has no choice but to act a certain way, when in fact there are specific people responsible for its behavior. We should not allow these people abdicate their reasoning by promoting the idea that the expected corporate action is the only possible course.
- gonzo 13y ago> But a company could legally "protect" their trademark by issuing yearly licenses for token compensation for products that they consider different enough, but the law might not. Nope. This is known as "naked licensing",and can lead to loss of the mark.
- mindslight 13y agoThen maybe the implementation is a non-binding letter of understanding between the two companies, stating that they both believe their business areas and marks are sufficiently different to avoid confusion. Any court that does not respect trademark owners reaching their own thought-out amicable agreement is an unjust one.
- josephlord 13y agoYou can lose trademarks that are not defended or become generic terms but on the other hand I think that they can be licensed to particular companies/usages. Allowing a company to use your trademark without entering an agreement is a bad idea.
- anigbrowl 13y agoWrong: http://www.inta.org/TrademarkBasics/FactSheets/Pages/LossofTrademarkRightsFactSheet.aspx http://www.inta.org/TrademarkBasics/FactSheets/Pages/LossofT... This is trademark law 101, not a 'mindless aphorism.' Any trademark lawyer will tell you that firms need to police the use of their marks if they wish to courts to enforce their rights in the mark. What basis do you have for claiming otherwise?
- mindslight 13y agoPlease read my follow up response (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7439468 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7439468). The legal environment is one specific context. I don't go around saying 'syntax error!' to anyone who misspeaks.
- anigbrowl 13y agoYour solution to this seems to be (morally) compulsory licensing instead of notifying customs authorities about the fact of an infringement. Exactly why should a firm grant a license to its direct competitor to make inferior-quality goods in the first firm's trade dress? I could just as easily argue that the fault for the waste here lies with the Chinese exporter who refuses to take back the unwanted product which infringes on someone else's trade dress. I don't buy the argument about import taxes making it too expensive, this is what entrepots are for.
- mindslight 13y agoIn this case, I do not believe that the firms are actually direct competitors. Fluke seems to somewhat agree, judging by this gesture of goodwill that they're giving Sparkfun. We hear of plenty of similar cases where some firm sends a C&D to a barely related firm, and a common refrain is that the first firm simply must defend their trademark in such a manner, leaving no room for judgment. I am pointing out that this is patently false.
- teacup50 13y ago
- gonzo 13y agoabsolutely wrong.