4 ms·
Seems fair to me. Note that he published all the estimates and then had people make predictions as a group, which is pretty much the way to extract wisdom-of-cr
by wpietri 13y ago
Seems fair to me. Note that he published all the estimates and then had people make predictions as a group, which is pretty much the way to extract wisdom-of-crowds effects.
I agree the estimator is biased, but in good part because of how people pick 5 from 100.
We are all biased in some ways. If a group shares the same biases, then a wisdom-of-crowds approach will yield a wrong answer in which everybody is confident. I think it's a fine lesson for people trying to work in this fashion.
- sp332 13y agoHe didn't have them estimate anything. They weighed things with a scale, then multiplied by 20.
- ska 13y agoBut they shouldn't all be doing the "same" thing!
- wpietri 13y agoFrom the instructions: "Explain that their goal is to estimate the total weight of all the candies in the bag. They can choose their 5 candies using any method–systematic sampling, random sampling, whatever. Whichever pair guesses closest to the true weight. they get the whole bag!" They knew their goal was to estimate the bag, and they were allowed to pick any five candies they wanted. If somebody picked in proportion to frequency, they'd be fine.
- baddox 13y agoBut as far as I can tell, the estimates didn't get worse after considering data from the crowd, which is implied by "unwisdom of crowds."