3 ms·
> Now call out to the students who are sitting near where you hid the envelope: “Um, uh, what’s that over there . . . is it an envelope??? Really? What’s inside
by baddox 13y ago
> Now call out to the students who are sitting near where you hid the envelope: “Um, uh, what’s that over there . . . is it an envelope??? Really? What’s inside? Could you open it up?” A student opens it and reads out what’s written on the sheet inside: “Your guesses are all too high!”
Maybe it's because I recently did some reading about magicians, but if I were one of the students I would be thinking that he could have any number of hidden envelopes with different predictions, and he just chose the one that ended up being correct. Of course, I'm deliberately missing the point of the story.
- sp332 13y agoThe point is that they all guessed low. The weight of the bag never changes, and there's no pretense that the teacher didn't know how much the bag weighed all along. You don't even need the envelope - you could just weigh the bag at the end. Same effect.
- rahimnathwani 13y ago"he just chose the one that ended up being correct" Yes, but it wouldn't be so impressive if he were to choose the envelope which said "your guesses were all wrong, and normally distributed about the actual value".