3 ms·
It's hard to figure out how bad this is because they don't give enough information about the other projects they compare to. For instance, they compare to 25 c
by tzs 13y ago
It's hard to figure out how bad this is because they don't give enough information about the other projects they compare to.
For instance, they compare to 25 construction worker deaths when preparing Sochi for the 2014 Winter Olympics. As far as I have been able to find with some Googling, Sochi officially involved 74000 construction workers, but an advocacy group for migrant workers says that there were around another 50000 working without permits. Let's take the high figure, and that gives us 1 death per 5000 workers.
So given 1.2 million migrant workers in Qatar, then if they were as safe as Sochi workers, we'd expect 240 deaths, so 900 does indeed look like it indicates they have some major safety problems.
The comparison to 11 who died during the Golden Gate Bridge construction seems pretty worthless. The FAQ at goldengatebridge.org says it was built by 10 prime contractors and the subcontractors, but also that they don't have any employment records from any of them so can't say how many workers were involved. It's also not a good project for comparison because it actually only had two fatal accidents. The first killed one man. The second killed 10 men, when a scaffold failed and the safety net did not catch them.
Up until that point, the project had set a record for remarkable safety. The norm for that kind of project was about one death per million dollars of construction, so getting that far with only one death was amazing, and even with all 11, I think they came in quite low. It was a $30 million project, so 30 deaths would have been normal. At that death rate, taking into account inflation, a project the size of the Qatar FIFA project would have, if safety was comparable to typical bridge projects at the time the Golden Gate was built, about 5000 deaths total for the project--which is close to what the article says they are looking at. However, bridge work is, I think, inherently more dangerous than much of the FIFA infrastructure work, and I'd hope bridge work today is more safe than bridge work was when the Golden Gate was built, so this is consistent with the Sochi comparison. Qatar does indeed to be doing something very wrong.
Conclusion: something very bad is indeed happening in Qatar.
- Crito 13y agoAs another data point, there were no deaths during the construction of London 2012 Olympic Park: http://www.hse.gov.uk/press/2012/hse-olympics-research.htm http://www.hse.gov.uk/press/2012/hse-olympics-research.htm There was a single death during the construction for the 2010 Winter Olympics in Vancouver, and 10 deaths during construction for the 2008 Beijing Olympics. http://constructiondatacompany.com/olympics-world-cup-construction-worker-deaths/ http://constructiondatacompany.com/olympics-world-cup-constr... (As you speculate for Sochi, there may also be reporting issues for the Beijing Olympics, but that is nothing but speculation on my part. I don't believe that the same could be said of the construction projects in UK or Canada.) There is something _really_ wrong going on in Qatar.
- kiba 13y agoThanks for spotting base rate neglect.