4 ms·
> Curious about the real-world results, I quickly grabbed a link to an artist I know, Andy Zipf, and put his song through Chordify. I played along with the resu
by baddox 13y ago
> Curious about the real-world results, I quickly grabbed a link to an artist I know, Andy Zipf, and put his song through Chordify. I played along with the results for most of the song, but wanted to see if the chords were right, directly from the source. I sent Zipf a message on Twitter asking and he responded, “Looks correct.”
> http://t.co/aMUnHJiQcP http://t.co/aMUnHJiQcP
Perhaps I'm foolish to question the artist about the chords of his own song, but it certainly doesn't look quite right to me. Each phrase in the verse starts on an A, and the algorithm misses that a few times. When the whole band starts, a lot more chord changes get missed, which seems odd to me based on the description of the algorithm.
Also, it would be nice if the tool attempted to identify a tonal center ("key") of the song, and use that to spell the chords more appropriately. For a lot of pop music, this would be fairly easy and reliable. In this song, the tonal center is clearly E, and it would be nice if the C#m wasn't spelled as Dbm.
- duskwuff 13y agoYeah, those chords certainly don't look quite right. There's some missed changes and some that show up a beat too early or too late. It's also missing a lot of subtleties, like 7th chords and inversions. For a much more blatant example of Chordify just failing to spot really obvious things, check out their results for "Get Lucky": http://chordify.net/chords/daft-punk-get-lucky-jay-lee http://chordify.net/chords/daft-punk-get-lucky-jay-lee This song has a completely fixed chord scheme (Bm/D/F#m/E). Each exception in the chord sheet is a mistake.