4 ms·
Awesome news... on a related note, John Carmack had a couple of recent, Sony-related Tweets with regard to their Project Morpheus announcement: "Trivia: I had
by Arjuna 13y ago
Awesome news... on a related note, John Carmack had a couple of recent, Sony-related Tweets with regard to their Project Morpheus announcement:
"Trivia: I had suggested to Sony that they try to hire Palmer Luckey before the Oculus kick starter." [1]
"Calibrate PS4 VR expectations: a game that ran 60 fps on PS3 could be done in VR (stereo 1080 MSAA low latency 60 fps) on PS4." [2]
[1] https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/446122463747776512 https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/446122463747776512
[2] https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/446271995668217857 https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/446271995668217857
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoHis second tweet makes an excellent point...
- mortenjorck 13y agoCould anyone with more background elaborate on what you think Carmack means with the second tweet? The PS4 already outputs 1080p with (varying algorithms of) antialiasing for several of its launch titles. I'd expect some rendering pipeline shortcuts to cut down on the latency that some operations incur and to achieve a constant 60 FPS, but a generational drop in graphical fidelity seems steep.
- alayne 13y agoHow are you going to push twice as many pixels without some quality tradeoff?
- mortenjorck 13y agoThat's just it, though. It's the exact same number of pixels. It's a single 1080p screen divided in two.
- higherpurpose 13y agoYou lose some performance with V-sync, which is necessary.
- mehwoot 13y agoNumber of pixels isn't the primary cost of rendering, unless you are using ray tracing.
- moistgorilla 13y agoyou are rendering from two different angles. its not the same as taking one rendered frame and cutting it in half
- ijk 13y agoCarmack has written a lot detailed information about the latency problem, which is much more demanding for VR, and about how to mitigate it: http://www.altdevblogaday.com/2013/02/22/latency-mitigation-strategies/ http://www.altdevblogaday.com/2013/02/22/latency-mitigation-...
- sparky 13y agoThe "stereo" part likely adds significant work (up to 2x), since you're rendering from two points of view.
- necubi 13y agoStereo rendering requires rendering the scene twice, once for each eye. Off the bat, this is almost twice as computationally intensive as rendering it once.
- mortenjorck 13y agoIt's rendering it twice, but at only half the resolution. Thinking about this more, the closest analog to stereo rendering would seem to be games with a split-screen mode. Which, in my experience, often does entail a performance hit (though certainly not a generation-sized one). My guess is that how much a second viewport affects performance is highly engine-dependent. Ironically, the one game I remember having the biggest delta from single-screen to split-screen is the Dreamcast version of Quake III: I distinctly recall the sharp drop in poly-count on the otherwise curvy rocket launcher.
- modeless 13y agoRendering the scene twice has overhead, so it would take extra time even if it was the same number of pixels total. But that's far from the only reason VR requires more power. Due to the distortion caused by the lenses the scene must be rendered at about 1.4x the normal resolution. Then there's a warping step that performs the inverse of the lens distortion, which is an additional cost. Also, good VR requires rendering at 90 Hz, not 60 Hz, so that's another 1.5x. Furthermore, frame tearing artifacts and FPS hiccups are much worse in VR, so you need extra headroom to eliminate them even in worst-case scenarios.
- sbierwagen 13y agoAlso, good VR requires rendering at 90 Hz The DK2 can only do 75 Hz. Anything more than that is wasted.
- modeless 13y agoDK2 isn't good enough. That's why it isn't the consumer version already. Palmer has said in interviews that the consumer version will be higher resolution and higher frame rate. The higher frame rate is required to enable low enough persistence without flickering.
- ekianjo 13y agoMany games on PS4 do NOT run at full 1080p resolution, they are rendered at lower resolution and upscaled. And on top of that, several games on PS4 do not run either at 60 fps. Performance wise, the new consoles are not THAT great, that's why the Occulus Rift team has been specifically said the new consoles will not be good enough for where they want to take VR.