3 ms·
It is just a billion dollar wealth transfer to people buying new cars or making new cars, from people who pay taxes and currently neither buy new cars nor make
by patio11 17y ago
It is just a billion dollar wealth transfer to people buying new cars or making new cars, from people who pay taxes and currently neither buy new cars nor make new cars. That is both the most positive and most damning thing I can say about it.
You would have exactly the same results if you instituted Cash for Computers, where you paid people money for increases in CPU clock speed. Wow, $1,000 rebates increased sales in computers and, wouldn't you know it, new computers are faster! Sweet! For people not buying computers, not quite so sweet.
- sachinag 17y agoNo one disputes this. However, the vast majority of cars and car parts sold in the U.S. are made here and are made in states below the median in average income; neither of those things are true for computers. Furthermore, this is a mildly net environmental positive.
- patio11 17y agoFurthermore, this is a mildly net environmental positive. It is clearly mildly net environmental positive if your definition of environmentalism is primarily of the "doing things which makes me feel environmentally conscious is environmentally positive" variety. If your definition of environmentally positive contains relationship to objective reality, however, [Citation Needed]. It is highly not obvious to me that moderate gains in fuel efficiency are net positive over the carbon footprint of producing an entire automobile. Indeed, it is entirely possible that the environmentally optimal choice was to pay people to not buy new cars where they otherwise would, thus idling big polluting factories and giving Captain Planet the day off. However, that wouldn't have accomplished the bailout of important political constituencies.
- jacquesm 17y ago"the vast majority of cars and car parts sold in the U.S. are made here and are made in states below the median in average income;" Large numbers of the cars sold are imports, and large amounts of the car parts for cars manufactured in the US are imported as well...
- oldgregg 17y agoExactly. This is nothing more than a reverse bail out. There wasn't the political will to give the money directly to automakers so they just waited a couple months and repackaged it.
- caseysoftware 17y agoOne thing I had forgotten until yesterday... what about college students, people just starting out, or the poor in general? I don't know about you guys, but in college I went through two of these clunkers, neither lasting more than two years. What happens to the price/availability of them as you take 2M of them off the road?
- roc 17y agoNot much. This program is only collecting up the 14mpg battering rams that no-one is buying; not even college students. (The difference in gas between a 'clunker' car and truck will approach the cost of the vehicles themselves in a year.) A large part of why this program is so popular is precisely because these particular vehicles are worth almost nothing without it.
- Scriptor 17y agoNot really the exact same results. Having low-speed CPUs doesn't quite lead us to drill for and burn more fossil fuels.
- ckinnan 17y agoIt is also a transfer from future taxpayers to wealthy bondholders (including the Chinese government), since 100% of this program is funded with borrowed money. At $3 billion, the new program size, Cash for Clunkers is four times larger than the U.S. government breast cancer research program. It says something about American priorities.
- roc 17y agoOnly if breast cancer research is underfunded. Not that this is a particularly good use of $3B. But the fact that it exists does not speak directly to American priorities.
- roc 17y agoTo be fair, as mileage requirements are part of the deal, this does have some (statistically debatable) impact on future resource usage that does impact all of us.