5 ms·
The Roman Empire lasted a thousand years, but I've never seen anything suggesting that they lionised the nuclear family. "Lay aside the concept of nuclear famil
by vacri 13y ago
The Roman Empire lasted a thousand years, but I've never seen anything suggesting that they lionised the nuclear family. "Lay aside the concept of nuclear family" didn't seem to stop them, and few cultures have lasted as long as they have.
The whole point about the term 'nuclear family' is that is refers to the (generally WASP) family structure in the nuclear age. It is specific to the modern age. Trying to retrofit it to historical civilisations is only going to end up in trying to explain away why this one or that one doesn't fit.
Strangely, you dismiss Ancient Greek culture as not being up to the task, but then grant that Florentine success was only because they copied old Greek culture. It's also worth mentioning that the Renaissance wasn't just central Europeans rediscovering archaic artifacts, as there was a host of new ideas and technologies being founded at the time, eventually accelerating into the Enlightenment period.
- dllthomas 13y ago"The whole point about the term 'nuclear family' is that is refers to the (generally WASP) family structure in the nuclear age." That's not my understanding at all. It refers to the "nucleus" of parents and children, as opposed to extended family.
- vacri 13y agoIt seems I am wrong with the definition, or rather am using an uncommon variant of the term. Still, living with extended family has been pretty common before the age of pensions.
- dllthomas 13y agoAgreed, though it's never been absurdly uncommon.
- FD3SA 13y agoA nitpick that has caused much confusion in the comments below: The nuclear family is the most basic form of family, and is certainly not opposed to an extended family. An extended family is a superset of a nuclear family. All families by definition must include the subset of the nuclear family, and thus it is the minimum requirement to fall into the set of "All possible families". For the set of all families F, there exists an element N = "nuclear family" such that N is a subset of F.
- vacri 13y agoThis is not true. If the children don't live with the parents, it's not a nuclear family. If one parent is dead or the parents don't live together, it's not a nuclear family. If dad's abusive and mum can't cope, and the grandparents are taking care of the kids at their place, it's not a nuclear family - the supposed 'nucleus' is not there. If there are no children, but adult siblings live together, they are a family, but not a nuclear one. My old boss took in a couple of teenagers from up the road when their mother was caught cheating and fled, never to be seen again, and the father was a pilot, always away, and utterly useless with kids. So here you have a situation where there is a sort of stepmother (no formal adoption) taking care of two kids (who come to see her as mum), a separate father who's not really in their lives, and a biological mother who has never been seen since. It's hard to see how terming that fractured family as a 'nuclear family' allows the phrase to have any useful meaning whatsoever.
- cafard 13y agoAbout 30 years ago, some wise-guy cartoonist came up with the expression "tactical nuclear family."
- FD3SA 13y agoYou are speaking of time variance. At some point in time, by definition, the nuclear family was present. It takes a male and a female to produce an embryo. At this point, the nuclear family is created. What happens afterwards is of course a combination of choice and probability, as your plethora of examples indicate. The only thing that is important in my assertion is whether the nuclear family unit is purposefully maintained by the parents, or not. The many reasons outside of the parents' control which may contribute to its dissolution are not part of this discussion (accidental death, dislocation, disease, etc.). As with any problem, we must be careful in defining our variables and assumptions, and minimize both in order to reduce the complexity of the problem, but not so much that the problem being solved becomes trivial.
- dllthomas 13y agoIn principle, the father could have died before the embryo was created - either during the time between intercourse and conception, or further decoupled with sperm banks &c.