3 ms·
You've got it backwards. Compare: "Because he's a nitwit, his arguments are wrong." = Ad Hominem "Because his arguments are wrong, he's a nitwit." = Not Ad Ho
by Terr_ 13y ago
You've got it backwards. Compare:
"Because he's a nitwit, his arguments are wrong." = Ad Hominem
"Because his arguments are wrong, he's a nitwit." = Not Ad Hominem
- alexqgb 13y agoBingo. It's impossible to point out that someone is blatantly lying without drawing attention to the fact that they are the sort of person who would blatantly lie. Character and speech are inseparable. As the line from Shakespeare says "Speak, so that I may see thee." Indeed, we are constantly evaluating the intelligence, integrity, goodwill, and authority of people based—in large part—on what they say. It's absurd to think that we cannot demolish an argument as dishonest, stupid, ill-informed, or made in bad faith because doing so would inevitably imply the same of the speaker. One of the he best reasons for maintaining a culture of free speech is that it permits the dangerous idiots to self-identify.