10 ms·
Read foreign country as US here too. Basically they can record everything and a constitutionally defined "search" doesn't occur unless a human search and looks
by rdtsc 13y ago
Read foreign country as US here too.
Basically they can record everything and a constitutionally defined "search" doesn't occur unless a human search and looks at the information.
Binney and other were talking about this even long before Snowden.
So what happens now, everything you do gets recorded, stored in their data center and kept for decades. As soon as you do anything they deem suspicious they might find you downloaded strange foot fetish porn when you were in college and try to blackmail you.
- samstave 13y agoEchelon and Carnivore. We have been talking about this since the 80s....
- effdee 13y agoThere have also been rumors about Amdocs [1] being kind of the Israeli counterpart. They do billing for telcos (i.e. determine who talked to whom for how long). The list of their customers is quite impressive. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amdocs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amdocs
- contingencies 13y agoThese 'rumours' are more like an open secret inside the industry. Personally I have seen billing APIs at AT&T (US) and T-Mobile (US) which are semi-equivalent. For one of those, calls go straight to an Amdocs domain on an AS hosted outside of the carrier. Of course, few people will see these now since Google Play canned external billing APIs (removing most of the interest here) and most new projects choose to access carrier billing via international aggregators (since integrating with one carrier can take months of pain, if you even have enough of a case to bother, and if they even talk to you). For NFC stuff, most US carriers are combining forces to produce a new API which will effectively similarly distance any integrators. The reason I got a look was we were developing the flagship app for Samsung Galaxy series device launch in the US, and the carriers were all on board with it. An older, long term IT veteran friend of mine who recently retired in Australia and chaired the mobile phone number portability multi-carrier technical implementation roundtable told me he was essentially fired (contract not renewed) for opening up an inquiry in to the wasteful billing practices at one particular Australian carrier. It turned out they were using Amdocs. He described making a decision, being forced to sit through a presentation, making the same decision, being forced to sit through another presentation, until the end of this contract period. This and other sources concur: the Amdocs billing stuff's like cancer. Once they're in your network, you can't get rid of them. If I were a national privacy authority or the European Data Protection Supervisor, I'd walk in to all my carriers, seize all third party billing systems, dump out disk images, and analyze them top to bottom in a nationally transparent, multi-party audit citing national security / privacy.
- res0nat0r 13y agoEvidence?
- cracell 13y agoThe article is evidence of the capability. And if you look at other leaks you see a clear pattern of them vacuuming up all the data they possibly can. Then take into consideration their budget and various data centers and it seems that they are capable of doing this at any scale desired. So they've shown the desire and capability. It's not direct evidence but it's pretty strong.
- res0nat0r 13y agoSure, but collecting and recording phone calls of US citizens is illegal and there hasn't been any evidence of this happening. Metadata of who you called and when has never been protected by the 4th Amendment so we can head that off...
- bigiain 13y ago"Illegal" in the same way that saying "No" to congress when the real answer was "Yes" is. Then later explaining that iw was "the least possible untruthful answer". The NSA have twisted their use of language - to try and claim that "recording phone calls of US citizens" isn't an illegal act until a human being listens to one of those recordings. I'm 99.999% sure that a "jury of peers" would not interpret the law that way. (Which might be why the need "special courts" without juries…)
- saraid216 13y ago> they might find you downloaded strange foot fetish porn when you were in college and try to blackmail you. So, you'll join the fight to make this a non-scandalous point of concern, right?
- dictum 13y agoThat's how I feel about revenge porn/leaked nude photos and videos of non-underage people in general. There should be legal consequences for people who leak this content against the wish of the people depicted, but I feel the media often plays up the narrative that people shouldn't take nude pictures (a pragmatic approach, but not the best going forward) and never mentions the silliness of reacting harshly to other people's sexuality. However, the pragmatic approach is still needed in a world where many people can attack you for your idiosyncrasies. Depending on your current situation, you won't lose your job and your particular interest will become only a minor office joke, but when you run for Congress, the masses may still care too much about it. As someone mentioned on HN, the advantage of being transparent is that you can weaponize it — "I do (thing) and if that worries you, it's your problem, not mine". And start downloading kinds of porn you have no interest in, just to confuse the snoops ;)
- thibauts 13y agoThis is really nauseating. Which kind of world are we letting happen ?
- Shivetya 13y agothe spooks are merely taking a liking to how politicians operate their political campaigns. Nothing secret is beyond a court order or, a friend in the right place.
- wreegab 13y ago> Read foreign country as US here too. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mHhVhud8_kE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mHhVhud8_kE
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dan_bk 13y ago> As soon as you do anything they deem suspicious they might find you downloaded strange foot fetish porn At least long term, it's more like: As soon as you are a political opponent... (Thinking back, General Petraeus' fatal love affair emails that surfaced suddenly may have been such an instance.)
- csandreasen 13y agoIf the country that this article was referring to was the US, do you really think that Barton Gellman would let a scoop go like that? I'm sure the first response will be something alluding to the US government secretly threatening the author if he revealed this, to which I would preemptively point out that this is the same man who has yet to receive any legal indictment and continues to walk the streets freely after revealing the PRISM program last year.