4 ms·
Minecraft is an interesting case study here, in that it deliberately throws away realistic graphics in favor of a comprehensively mutable environment. It's inte
by PhasmaFelis 13y ago
Minecraft is an interesting case study here, in that it deliberately throws away realistic graphics in favor of a comprehensively mutable environment. It's interesting how that seemed like such a totally unprecedented idea at the time.
- danso 13y agoI'm not sure where Minecraft came in the recent era of gaming...since it was built in 2009, that was well after games started being big on iOS, and some of those big games went for 8-bit as a way to maintain a modern sense of style and artistic quirk with the limited dev and system resources. Also, notch got some inspiration from Dwarf Fortress, which made an even more extreme sacrifice of graphics (the precursor to Dwarf Fortress was a 3D game that was too difficult to develop for). Either way, who could've guessed back in 2004ish that pixelated retro games (including FTL, TowerFall, and countless iOS hits) would be what gaming would look like 10 years later?
- lazugod 13y ago> Either way, who could've guessed back in 2004ish that pixelated retro games (including FTL, TowerFall, and countless iOS hits) would be what gaming would look like 10 years later? Flash games were probably the 2004-era precedent.
- AJ007 13y agoIt wasn't unprecedented, just look at Dwarf Fortress. Tarn threw out all graphics in exchange for focusing on an incredibly complex and deeply layered game -- with an environment that is fully constructable and has both a geological and cultural history. Once the 3D accelerator become an item all gamers had, (perceptually) it appeared all major game develop shifted to producing "photorealistic" graphics. We ended up with an endless trail of games that basically produced the same thing. I wonder, what would happen if the budget of something like Call of Duty was spent on a game with Minecraft or even Ascii graphics? Perhaps a total disaster, but what could be produced if it was done really well?
- dasil003 13y agoThe current state of Dwarf Fortress probably is within an order of magnitude of the number man hours in it as an early Call of Duty. The difference is that the work on Call of Duty is mostly art which is trivially parallelizable, whereas the work on Dwarf Fortress is the engine which is not parallelizable to anywhere near the same degree.
- mnw21cam 13y agoOnce upon a time there was an open source game called "Cube" which was a first person shooter. It allowed in-game multi-player level editing, with all the occlusion and lighting recomputed on the spot. It was superseded by Sauerbraten, which improved the level structure to allow multiple floors, but didn't run as quickly due to the calculations being a bit harder.
- andrey-p 13y agoA game with very stylised graphics will always win over a game with very realistic graphics as far as I'm concerned. If you've got a game with unassuming graphics it's a lot easier to focus on the gameplay. Alternatively, stylising things _just right_ can get you a lot further in creating a specific atmosphere - games like Limbo work because everything fits together so perfectly.