5 ms·
> In the skydiver's LIF under the conditions above, the first particle (the lower particle) would always be moving in the positive x direction in the LIF slower
by pdonis 13y ago
> In the skydiver's LIF under the conditions above, the first particle (the lower particle) would always be moving in the positive x direction in the LIF slower than the second (upper) particle, regardless of the skydiver's speed relative to the Earth, and regardless of the second particle's speed relative to the Earth (i.e. it doesn't need to be escaping).
I'm responding to this separately because it was easier than trying to cram this plus my other responses into one post. If you are going to talk about what is or is not the same in the skydiver LIF and the LIF falling through the black hole's horizon, you have to first make sure the initial conditions are set up the same. Here's how you would do that:
(1) The LIF is in free fall, i.e., the astronaut/skydiver who is at rest in the LIF is freely falling in the gravitational field of some central body.
(2) At time t = 0 in the LIF, the astronaut/skydiver meets an outgoing light ray. (In the LIF falling through the black hole's horizon, this outgoing light ray is the horizon; in the skydiver LIF, it's just whatever outgoing light ray happens to be passing him at t = 0. Within the LIFs, there is no way to distinguish the two.)
(3) At some time t = minus epsilon in the LIF, the astronaut/skydiver releases a probe that flies outward at nearly the speed of light. (This is a key point that I don't think you understand: the initial condition in the LIF is that the relative velocity of the probe and the astronaut/skydiver must be the same. It is not that the probe's initial velocity is escape velocity. "Escape velocity" is a global concept, not a local concept; it has no meaning within the LIF. It so happens that, in the LIF falling through the black hole horizon, the first probe gets launched at a velocity that, globally, is just sufficient for it to escape to infinity, whereas in the skydiver LIF, the probe's initial velocity is way, way more than needed for it to escape; but there's no way to tell that from within the LIF.)
(4) At some time t = plus epsilon in the LIF, the astronaut/skydiver releases a second probe that flies outward at a speed even closer to the speed of light than the first probe.
These conditions are perfectly possible to set up in both LIF's (the skydiver LIF and the LIF falling through the black hole's horizon), and within the LIF's, there is no way to tell which LIF you are in; every observation within the LIF will be the same for both. The second probe will move closer to the first probe (while they are both within the LIF); but the second probe will be falling behind the light ray that passes the astronaut/skydiver at t = 0.
It's true that, once all these objects exit the LIF, things will be very different in the two cases. In the skydiver case, the outgoing light ray will catch up with and pass the first probe. In the black hole horizon case, it won't. But there's no way to tell that from within the LIF.
It's also true that the r coordinates of these objects behave very differently, even within the LIF. In the skydiver case, all three of the objects that are moving outward (the first probe, the light ray, and the second probe) are increasing their r coordinates (and rather rapidly at that). In the black hole case, the first probe has (very slowly) increasing r, the light ray (the horizon) has constant r, and the second probe has (very slowly) decreasing r. But as I said in the other post I made in response to your latest, the r coordinate is a global coordinate, not a coordinate in the LIF; and there is no law of physics that says the relationship between local coordinates within an LIF and global coordinates must be the same for every LIF. In fact, it obviously can't be, because the whole point of the equivalence principle is that LIFs that look the same locally can occur in parts of spacetime that look very different on a global scale.
- fargolime 13y agoThanks for that explanation. Most of it I agree with. > There is no way to tell which LIF you are in There is a way. To keep it simple, let's assume the probes are test particles. In the skydiver's frame the second probe will overtake the first probe, given a sufficiently small epsilon. (We can always make that epsilon small enough that it's within the duration of the LIF.) In the astronaut's frame, for the same epsilon, the second probe won't overtake the first probe. The same experiment, different results, violating the equivalence principle.
- pdonis 13y ago> (We can always make that epsilon small enough that it's within the duration of the LIF.) NO, YOU CANNOT. Sorry to shout, but not only have I already said this is false (several times if you include the previous thread I linked to), I have linked to a computation that proves it's false. So once again, you are basing your reasoning on a false assumption, and therefore you are naturally reaching false conclusions. (Note that my computation proves something stronger: that the distance required, extrapolated from the LIF, for the outgoing light ray the astronaut/skydiver passes at t = 0 in the LIF to catch the first probe, is much larger than the size of the LIF. If this is true, it must also be true that the second probe can't catch the first probe within the LIF.) To briefly expand on what the computation I linked to shows: the smaller you make epsilon, the smaller the difference in velocities between the two probes can be (because the first probe has to be launched at escape velocity, and the smaller you make epsilon, the closer escape velocity gets to the velocity of light). And the smaller the velocity difference, the larger the catch-up distance, in the same proportion. So decreasing epsilon increases the catch-up distance extrapolated from the LIF such that the extrapolated catch-up distance remains much larger than the size of the LIF. (Again, my computation proves something stronger: that the catch-up distance required for the outgoing light ray, extrapolated from the LIF, increases as epsilon decreases, such that the catch-up distance remains much larger than the size of the LIF.) To expand on the expansion just a bit more: remember that, in order for there to be any potential issue to discuss at all, two things must be true: (1) the initial conditions must match in both LIFs; (2) the global prediction of whether or not the second probe catches the first must be different for the two scenarios. Requirement #2 is what forces us to change the initial velocity of the first probe when we change epsilon; requirement #1 is what forces us to change the initial velocity of the first probe in both LIFs when we change epsilon. (Actually, to expand one more bit, there is a third condition: the LIF size over which we can do the comparison at all must be the smaller of the two LIF sizes. Otherwise there would be no point to the comparison, since we could always just call globally flat spacetime an "LIF" and find some difference between it and an LIF in any curved spacetime by looking at effects that happen outside the range of the curved spacetime LIF.)