4 ms·
It's not about the risk at all. Anyone who takes a job takes the described risk. The cleaning personal does too. How would the place look like if it wasn't cle
by ThomPete 13y ago
It's not about the risk at all.
Anyone who takes a job takes the described risk. The cleaning personal does too. How would the place look like if it wasn't clean.
I don't mind him getting 20m. What i do mind is this naive idea of why people make the money they sometimes do.
He took no risk any other person going to work everyday didn't.
- epi8 13y agoThat's a little unfair. I work at an 30-year-old engineering company with the most market share in our field. If my company goes down, that's probably because someone did something illegal, or entire economies of multiple countries have just bellied-up. I take very minimum risks in that regard. A new start-up, though? Much higher risk of failure.
- ThomPete 13y agoIt's not unfair at all. Running a restaurant is like running a startup only you don't get to a point where it just runs itself. And with low margins it's most often not even a good business either. In fact the better quality the lower margin. Talk about taking a risk. I have no problem with the chef getting 20mio, what I have a problem with is the claim of risk as if he is risking anything anyone else isn't.
- Iftheshoefits 13y agoYour risk isn't that the company goes belly up, it's that internal politics churns in such a way that you find yourself the next victim of a witch hunt, that your unit's contribution is identified as having become obsolete or lacking to the point where it's time to cut, etc. Your risks aren't minimum; they're different.
- michaelochurch 13y agoHe took no risk any other person going to work everyday didn't. He obviously took enough risk that Google was willing to give him stock options. Google didn't make that offer to be nice. It was a business decision. I'm siding with Google (and the chef) here. Because it didn't have the money at the time to pay him enough to fully offset the negatives (which may have been opportunity cost or long hours, not necessarily company-wide risk) it offered him stock. It wasn't being nice. That paid off handsomely for him. You'd be right to argue that most working people are undercompensated for the suffering and the risk that they take on in their jobs. That, however, goes far beyond the Google chef. It's a systemic problem. As a society, we've failed to find anything within even a factor of 5 of a fair balance between capital and labor.
- ThomPete 13y agoYou mean he took a paycut so they compensated by giving him stocks. Again I have nothing against him making 20. Just don't claim that he somehow made a risk. He didn't and if that is the reason why someone should get stock then most people going to work every day should get stock.
- michaelochurch 13y agoHow is taking a pay cut not taking a risk? He put capital (his time, not fully compensated) at risk. then most people going to work every day should get stock. Personally, I'd rather have it in salary. 0.05% of a 40-person company isn't going to motivate me worth shit. It has the opposite effect (uncanny valley). I'd much rather work for a hedge fund and be reasonably paid for my skills. Unless it's substantial, equity is a bad sign for me. Why? Because 0.05% of a 40-person company ("checkbox equity") won't motivate me in the least, but it will motivate other people, which means I'm going to be competing (on hours, indignity, and suffering) against people who haven't done the math on their pathetic shares and are delusional and clueless. That's like wrestling a guy on PCP; it's better not to.
- mlieberman85 13y agoHow so? He definitely took a risk. He is taking an elevated risk because the company might not be there in 6 months. Especially with a young startup. It's one thing if the guy is becoming a chef at lets say Mastercard or Bank of America or some major company that there's a reasonable expectation that the company isn't going to go out of business tomorrow. With that said I actually think stock options are a good incentive for all employees. It provides some reasonable guarantees on both parties. On the one hand the employee is given incentive to work hard because the more productive they are the better the company does and the better the stock does. Also it gives them something nice in case they get laid off and the stock goes up. Also the company sees those same benefits. The employee will probably work harder and more productive because they have more incentive to.
- salgernon 13y agoYou've obviously never worked in a support position of a failed startup. Those are the people that don't get paid - the developers having been able to see the writing on the wall weeks before the paychecks stop coming. The support staff (tech support, office managers) keep coming to works as the CEO promises paychecks "by the end of this week". Its not like its trivial to find another similar job on a weeks notice, and living paycheck to paycheck has a paralyzing effect. An established company has far less risk for support staff.
- ThomPete 13y agoWas that to me? I am agreeing with you? So not sure it was to me.