3 ms·
Both articles on the front page here fail to mention that he was doing this as an advertised commercial service.
by baddox 17y ago
Both articles on the front page here fail to mention that he was doing this as an advertised commercial service.
- jrockway 17y agoAuto mechanics work on cars as an advertised commercial service. It turns out that tinkering with parts should not be a crime. (Yes, this guy was doing it to pirate video games. But handgun manufacturers build guns solely to murder other human beings, and auto mechanics can install equipment that allows you to exceed the speed limit. Neither of those are crimes, so why should modifying a game console be one?)
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jodrellblank 17y agoIt turns out that tinkering with parts should not be a crime. When did it turn out? It neither 'should' nor 'should not' be a crime, objectively, that I can see. Neither of those are crimes, so why should modifying a game console be one? You can't kill or speed without large and noticable external signals, such as a speeding car or a dead/missing person. You can also target shoot and race on private tracks. You can pirate video games without any significantly noticable events, and there isn't much else you can do with a chipped console. Video game piracy has more justification for legal blocks earlier in the process.
- calcnerd256 17y agoHomebrew isn't much else?
- otto 17y agoor linux for that matter? I purchased several original xbox's and modded them to run linux for a clustering project.
- CWuestefeld 17y agoI know folks who have a chipped XBox, primarily to run XBMC (XBox Media Center). This isn't pirated software at all, it's open source. But it's a great way to get media off a home server and play it on your entertainment center. The hacking of the box is only because of MS's locking out 3rd parties.
- cookiecaper 17y agoThere are plausible reasons to modify a game console that aren't just pirated games. I haven't followed modchips et al recently, but historically a mod chip was required to use any non-standard software at all (for instance, installing a different operating system like XBMC). I think it's the same today.
- TrevorJ 17y ago"handgun manufacturers build guns solely to murder other human beings" That's a gross oversimplification of a complex issue. Very few people obtain a handgun legally for the purpose of Murdering somebody. (Less than 1% of legally obtained firearms are used in a crime) The primary reason to own one is for personal protection which implies the direct preservation of life. Ignoring that fact is intellectually dishonest.
- forinti 17y agoOwning a guns doubles your chances of getting killed by one, so it only really augments your perception of safety.
- TrevorJ 17y agoSource please. Also, statistically, do gun owners live in unsafer environments to begin with, hence the perceived need for ownership?
- forinti 17y agoThis is a highly controversial article, I admit: http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/abstract/329/15/1084 http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/abstract/329/15/1084 Gun ownership is widespread in the US, and lots of people have them in perfectly safe regions. So do they not create a source of danger where there was none? Accidents do happen. In my country, gun deaths went down considerably after the police started taking them out of circulation. As one police officer put it, bar fights became a lot less deadly in the suburbs.
- baddox 17y agoHandgun manufacturers don't build guns solely to murder, that's a ridiculous claim, and I doubt if you even believe it. I don't know of any car that can't exceed most speed limits anyway, but the mechanic analogy is slightly better. In fact, I don't think console modification should be a crime, but I think the console companies should be able to initiate a civil case.
- teej 17y agoThis is a very, very important detail. I was talking to a VP of a game company in Europe about 3rd party servers for games like World of Warcraft. He said that they don't really pay attention to them, except for when they run it for a profit. The minute $$ is involved, they have a special phone # at the FBI to call and get the servers raided the next day.
- jacquesm 17y agoSo what. You sell it, you should lose every right to control it. As soon as you ask somebody to pay for something you lose control over every aspect of it. If that is not your intention you should rent your devices to people. What really amazes me is that the law enforcement people are so eager to comply with this stuff that they even set up a special hotline for it. As far as I'm concerned these kids are doing honest work, they're breaking a chain of control that should not even be there.
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoIf that is not your intention you should rent your devices to people. That's more or less what these companies are doing. If you read the mouseprint, you're effectively buying a licence to use their device on their terms. :P
- jacquesm 17y agoIf I'm not paying a monthly I'm buying it. If there is a bill of sale I'm buying it. If there is a rental agreement and I have to return it at the end of the agreement then I'm renting it. More or less doesn't cut it.
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoI'm not defending their approach, only pointing it out.
- ricaurte 17y agoI have a feeling if he made this a centerpiece of the defense case he could have it appealed all the way to the Supreme Court. If you "buy" something, you own it. Similar to the car comment, if you buy a new home, it's not like you get it with a EULA that says you can't modify it, although home owners associations act in a similar manner. He could also potentially counter-sue with a class-action lawsuit claiming that the video game systems makers committed fraud by way of falsely advertising to people that they were "buying" the game systems, when in fact, they were actually leasing them.
- 17y ago