2 ms·
Yes, we should be more like the 'free' US, what with their frequently paramilitarised police and 'free speech zones', law-enforcement drones and police kicking
by vacri 13y ago
Yes, we should be more like the 'free' US, what with their frequently paramilitarised police and 'free speech zones', law-enforcement drones and police kicking down doors because "I smelled pot", and an incarceration rate five times higher with people doing considerably longer sentences (despite the consitutional requirement for no excessive punishment).
Australia is not the bleak wasteland you paint it as, and it's not a police state. Using this kind of hyperbole does no-one any favours. Do you really think that Australians fear their neighbours like the people in East Germany did? The PM recently said that the government broadcasting agent should not be so negative about the government and should be more like it's cheer squad. He was pilloried by the private press for saying such a thing.
I'm interested to know what privacy and personal rights you think the US has that Australia doesn't. The US has 'bear arms', true. It has slightly greater private freedom of speech, but in practice slightly worse freedom of speech for the press.
As for the content of the constitution, that's not the way we do law. Just because the US shoves every silly thing into their constitution (or at least tries to), it doesn't mean that it doesn't exist for us if it's not in our constitution. We have shitloads of law outside the constitution. Hardly surprising, since in the US, you only require politicians to amend the constitution, but in Australia, you need to hold a referendum. And even in the US, the vast bulk of nattering about the constitution is just grandstanding - a law is a law. Being in the constitution simply makes it harder to repeal. Not being in the constitution doesn't make it any less legally binding, just easier to strike down.
- wavefunction 13y agoAlso, two entire states in America just legalized cannabis completely, Australia does not share land borders with its neighbors, and the US Constitution requires no "cruel or unusual punishments" which is different from "excessive." Those are just three points to the generalized rubbish you've posted in support of whatever argument you're making. I don't say this to be mean but to cut to the quick and point out you're not posting anything particularly insightful when you gloss over inconvenient realities in either Australia or America.
- vacri 13y agoTwo entire states have legalised cannabis? Cool. Australia doesn't have stop-and-frisk anywhere, and certainly doesn't have politicians proudly calling for support of the practise. That's a pretty fundamental abuse of freedom right there, that for no reason, an authority can just stop you and search your person. Yes, there is police harassment like anywhere, but it's not codified into law and openly defended by politicians. As for 'unusual' punishments, excessive sentencing is a 'cruel or unusual' punishment. My point was that the US is not the bastion of freedom that it's PR suggests. I was pointing out the US Bill of Rights still doesn't prevent these abuses from happening, as people seem to mythologise that document. I've mentioned in other threads that the level of freedom between the two countries really isn't that dissimilar - it's just that the idea that the US is the paragon of freedom above and beyond its contemporaries just simply is not true. Anyway, I mentioned two things about Australia that you are apparently debunking: that we don't edit the constitution in the normal process of politics, because it requires a referendum to do so; and that we don't fear our neighbours like people in East Germany did. I said "Australia is not a bleak wasteland" and you say I'm glossing over reality? I wonder if you've ever been here, or if you merely think The Road Warrior is a documentary? If you happen to be Australian, then you've got a massive dollop of cultural cringe going on. It's certainly not a police state as the OP put forward, and neither is the US or the UK.