3 ms·
There's a legitmate point in there somewhere, so I think the article deserves to be voted up. And before I start my critique: I'm a libertarian. I agree that t
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
There's a legitmate point in there somewhere, so I think the article deserves to be voted up.
And before I start my critique: I'm a libertarian. I agree that there is a real problem that needs attention.
But the delivery was awful! First he picks Iraq as an example to make a point that people of both political spectrums can understand -- not a good choice due to all the controversy of what's going on there. Fred the AQ operative from Libya blowing up a Shi'ite mosque is not really fighting for self-determination. Some are, no doubt. But picking this example really screws up the argument. It sounds like "we won in Iraq so something really evil must come out of it!", kind of reasoning. Ugh.
Then we have the premise that robots can be used for counter-insurgency. While I agree that there are many pointy-headed folks at DoD who think this, it's not the way counter-insurgency works. The whole idea is to get real, live troops out into the field and interacting with the local population, protecting it. Protect the people first. Killer robots hosing down random houses with tear gas and tasers really don't meet that criteria.
At some point after the first few paragraphs, I pictured the author as waving their hands around in the air wildly and screaming "The robots are coming! The robots are coming!" Probably not fair to the author, but dude, you lost me. Calm down a bit and make a cogent point with supporting evidence. Tell a story. Do something except rant on for so long. Towards the end I was just skimming. You'd made your point and life is short.
"By globally respecting the right to self-defense recognized in America as the Second Amendment we can avoid an entire set of grossly negative and destructive futures."
But the Second Amendment is titled "The Second Amendment to the United States Constitution". It all kind of fits together as one huge compromise (the Bill of Rights) added on to the Constitution to get ratification. Other countries have already disarmed their populations and are very good at oppressing them and preventing change without robots.
Even the U.S. took the ability of most people from owning combat firearms away in the 1930s as a way to prevent crime. As a world, we've already mostly lost our ability to enact forceful change. Those days are gone. You're late to the party, and while it's great this robot thing has woken you up, robots are just another tool in a very large toolbox that states use to keep the folks in line.
Finally, this is technology. It's not just the U.S., or DoD. This is the incredible, wonderful, terrible, and awful march of progress. You'd have a better chance stopping a freight train with rubber bands than to make a dent in the inexorable advance of new ways to control people.
So less ranting and more analysis and recommendations, please?
- RobGR 17y agoI wish to nitpick your discription of the 1930s federal gun law as taking away the ability of most people to own combat firearms. That law was rather carefully crafted to try to avoid taking away the right to own "combat" firearms, because those firearms are exactly the ones to which the 2d amendment would apply. Rather, it focused on cannons and bombs, which they could argue were not personal arms, and on what it called "tools of assassination", silenced weapons and automatic weapons. Automatic weapons were not common combat firearms at the time, most soldiers would have rifles that were bolt action, a few semi-automatic. At the time the law was passed the New Dealers were fighting the Supreme Court, which was overturning a lot of their grand plans, so the gun law was crafted with that in mind. It doesn't even technically ban the "class III" weapons, it just requires an excise tax which is difficult to pay. It is still probably an unconstitutional law, and it's benefits in fighting crime are probably not very big -- the old tommy gun gangsters of the 1930s were not driven out of business by lack of automatic weapons, they were tracked down and killed and arrested by traditional police work (some of which was unconstitutional in other ways). A larger objection I have is to your claim "we've already mostly lost out ability to enact forceful change. Those days are gone." I think the general trend from 1776 to now, has been towards a more just, more democratic, more ideal society. There are major deviations on the way, and we are currently regressing, but still ahead of where we were in 1960, I think. I also think robot technology will not always benefit just the rich and powerful in conflicts. Hobbiests can already build model aircraft which carry a WRT54G and do auto-pilot; when Palestinians hack a cell phone onto a model plane and send a few ounces of incendiary or a grenade on a long, slow trip to be fairly precisely delivered via GPS or cell tower positioning, then you will know the temporary imbalence is ending.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI think you misunderstood me. I agree that society is more just now -- a lot of progress has been made. By "forceful change" I meant the government is no longer so afraid of armed civilians as it was, say, during the Whiskey Rebellion. Jefferson's quip that "A little rebellion now and then... is a medicine necessary for the sound health of government." hardly seems apt in its original meaning. Very interesting piece of history regarding the 1930s laws. Thanks for the correction.