3 ms·
The most effective language tuition I've ever had consisted of daily one-on-one lessons with a tutor who would make me talk and correct me on the fly. If I mad
by idlewords 17y ago
The most effective language tuition I've ever had consisted of daily one-on-one lessons with a tutor who would make me talk and correct me on the fly. If I made systematic errors, he would go over the point of grammar and we woudl do some drills. Every night I had to write a one to three page essay, which he would eviscerate the next day.
Having studied a number of languages, I've come to believe that being forced to speak and write at the outer limit of your ability is the most effective way to learn a foreign language (listening and reading will come effortlessly as a side effect). However this is somewhat expensive, emotionally tiring (adults aren't used to the experience of constant failure and correction), and it can be hard to find someone who will really pounce on every mistake.
I've found intensive immersion programs with small classes to be a good second-best, especially at the beginner level where progress is very rapid and you have a chance to internalize proper phonetics and grammar.
A possibly useful image: you have about ten thousand wrong sentences you have to get out of you before you are speaking the language well, so you need to find someone who will help you get them out of your system as efficiently as possible.
- mgreenbe 17y agoI agree heartily. Native speakers who are willing to correct you---and not default to some better, common language---are the best resource possible. I've been in a few immersion programs, and they're all okay. The best I've seen was ulpan, in Israel. Recent immigrants are thrown together and taught Hebrew; since they don't necessarily have a common language, their medium of communication must be Hebrew. Since you're all learning together, mistakes are less embarrassing. In all, nothing beats being there: you have to go somewhere the language is spoken and force yourself to be a part of it.
- oPerrin 17y agoCan you tell us how you found this tutor? Did you interview multiple people? And finally how much did this kind of tutoring cost?
- trevelyan 17y agoWe actually provide this for mandarin as part of my business (http://popupchinese.com http://popupchinese.com). And if you're looking for a data point, we charge $25 for three 20 minute sessions a week. The workload ends up being about as intense as taking a regular night course, except that it is one-on-one with a teacher. Textbooks and traditional classrooms are way back on the curve. They prioritize the organizational problems of schools instead of the learning needs of students.
- idlewords 17y agoI was living in Buenos Aires at the time, and Googled around various language schools. I paid about $15/hour for a three-hour daily session. The fact that it was costing me a significant sum of money motivated me to work harder.