4 ms·
people install satellite security systems on $200K cars. Couldn't airlines do the same on a $100M plane.
by trhway 13y ago
people install satellite security systems on $200K cars. Couldn't airlines do the same on a $100M plane.
- JacobAldridge 13y agopeople fit 239 passengers in a plane. Couldn't manufacturers do the same with cars? Fallacy by analogy. It's a fair question (off hand), but it falls down when other factors are considered (cars don't normally drive for hours over water, for example).
- trhway 13y ago>Fallacy by analogy. or may be you just saw in my post an analogy to the fallacy by analogy >cars don't normally drive for hours over water, for example how that would affect the satellite communication?
- JacobAldridge 13y agoSee here for the long answer - http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-pacific-26544554 http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-pacific-26544554 The short answer, as I understand it, is: 1) Most communications technology, including satellites, is focused on where most people are communicating - ie, on land; ie, on 1/8th of the earth's surface 2) As you correctly point out, satellites over water aren't as obvious a problem as, say, mobile phone towers in the Indian Ocean, but the cost to retrofit existing aircraft is considered prohibitive given the rarity of this type of situation (ie, existing communication systems work well, and in this case seem to have been deliberately turned off anyway - so a different system is likely to have proved no more helpful).
- lostlogin 13y agoThere isn't much precedent for this, and the vague stories which do exist are uncommon. Car theft is common and is a real risk.
- jonah 13y agoYes, but due to regulations/training/maintenance/international standardization/etc. it's a major effort to do so.
- storborg 13y agoYes, and they do. For example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_dependent_surveillance-broadcast https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_dependent_surveillan... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aircraft_Communications_Addressing_and_Reporting_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aircraft_Communications_Addres... These systems were manually disabled.
- 001sky 13y agoPoint is a $100 spot device could be added (powered by Li AA's) as a backup system. This would have independent power supply and obviate the "need for cicuit breakers" being accessed. Or something like a lo-jack or whatever. Its completely embarassing to Boeing. Almost as bad as the pilot has a 64mb i phone and the [edit: voice recorders] holds only 2hrs? WTF. An Iphone might not itself survive, but the media allocations for the seem absyrdly low.
- Aloha 13y agoYes, but the FDR is designed to survive multi-g impacts - how well would that smart phone survive?
- TylerE 13y agoSolid state storage is pretty resilient.
- 001sky 13y agoThe spot device doesn't need to survive a crash, just needs to send out a GPS ping once every 10 minutes. ie to give a fix on where the crash is would be sufficient.
- TylerE 13y ago10 minutes isn't nearly enough. Remember you're talking about something moving at 8-10 miles per minute, 10 minutes, so worse case your solution will give a range about the size of Iowa.
- DigitalSea 13y agoYou make it sound so simple, when in reality it is anything but simple. Every component in a plane is tested extensively before it can be installed and used. When it comes to electronic components in a plane, things like interference to other aircraft, other components on the plane, power usage and interference to ground devices (radio stations, emergency frequencies, etc) are all tested and considered. Planes are massive powerhouses of technological wonder, adding something new into such a machine would take considerable amounts of time and even then once you've got it installed, who is going to maintain it? You've got to pay for access to a satellite for the data to be tracked, where is the data stored? Is the data encrypted? How do you make sure only the eyes intended to see the data see it and nobody else? What kind of redundancy is there if the satellite security system fails? Does the plane need bigger batteries to power such a device, where does the power come from? There are rules and processes to follow in the aviation industry and they're very strict. And that's just the hardware, then you've got to write the software, make sure it doesn't interfere with anything else on the plane, then you've got to make it work for different planes, planes wired differently, different hardware/software, controls. You're testing two different halves that make a whole. One does not simply just install a new piece of technology into a plane. There's no DIY kit you can buy from Tandy. Then there is a cost vs risk calculation thrown into the equation here. How often does a plane just vanish like this? It doesn't happen very often and probably not enough to warrant spending hundreds of millions of dollars implementing a terrorist proof tracking/data collection system. Cars are stolen everyday, it's a common thing, for planes it is not. If things were that easy, they would have already done so, trust me. Nobody wants to see their planes return more than the airline who paid for the plane, paid for the maintenance, paid for the staff & fuel and need it to help recoup the costs and make the business money. Are we also not forgetting planes have quite good data capturing and positioning systems already? The transponder was disabled which was the easy one (a flick of a switch) but the ACARS maintenance tracker was also disabled and as already highlighted, without advanced knowledge of the planes internals, isn't something you can just disable with the flick of a switch. Other advanced fall-back tracking methods were disabled, this isn't something your standard pilot would know about.
- trhway 13y ago>Cars are stolen everyday, it's a common thing, for planes it is not. from time to time planes crash over ocean and search for black boxes may take years like Air France 447 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France_Flight_447#Underwater_search http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France_Flight_447#Underwate...)
- quaunaut 13y agoFar as I know, if your car goes over the Indian Ocean you're gonna lose signal pretty quick, right?
- adamnemecek 13y agoIf only airlines employed someone with your acumen. You are most definitely the first person ever to have that thought. But now that that is out of the way there is nothing in the way.