5 ms·
They also omit the fact that the 4 digit code in the transponder is entered by the pilot. When I've flown with friends typically the transponder is set to 1200
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
They also omit the fact that the 4 digit code in the transponder is entered by the pilot. When I've flown with friends typically the transponder is set to 1200 until ATC tells them what number they want them to emit, and then the pilot sets that number and from then on they know who they are.
- davepage 13y agoIt is worth mentioning that transport aircraft carry Mode S [0] transponders which emit a unique ICAO 24 bit address assigned by aircraft registration. This data is available regardless the pilot-entered 4 octal digit Mode A transponder code. The transponder can still be turned off, however. This contrasts to small aircraft which typically have Mode A/C only (no mode S). [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aviation_transponder_interrogation_modes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aviation_transponder_interrogat...
- samstave 13y agoSo.... why? All airplanes should have a MAC address. No plane should have a user-servicable-power-switch to the transponder. Can you tell why the opposite woud be needed?
- maxerickson 13y agoIn case an electrical fault is detected. Protecting the passengers from the pilot is anyway a false goal. You can't really do it without removing the pilot.
- samstave 13y agoThis and: (electrical faults, interference with airport radars, safety of maintenance technicians). Sound like utter BS. Show me a case where an IN-FLIGHT transponder shutdown is a needed issue, or where this does not need a better engineered solution. Also - Don't tell me why this is not done (based on past issues) - tell me why this is impossible to fix. I challenge you to give me any reason in the universe which is acceptable for not tracking, in real time - uninterrupted streams, flying packages of hundreds of humans. Give me any reasonable response to why this is not something that should be fixed.
- maxerickson 13y agoIt's obviously not possible to give you a response that you find reasonable, so why bother trying again? But an electrical fire in a plane is sort of a real problem that there needs to be contingencies for. Planes doing something strange doesn't happen often enough for it to be the most important thing in the universe.
- samstave 13y agoObviously - so thanks for being defeatist.
- einhverfr 13y agoI don't think it is defeatist. The whole point of security is risk management. You address your most common risks first, and then the less common risks later. Electrical fires are more common than hijackings, especially after you figure in airport security. Therefore in plane design you worry about electrical fires far more than you do hijackings. Additionally this is the first incident of its kind. This is not a typical hijacking. In fact it is entirely unprecedented. For this reason it is a game changer, and I think you are right to point that out. But electrical fires are orders of magnitude more common so you aren't going to ever risk one based on a much less likely possibility here. To be honest, I have faith that investigators will eventually track the culprits down. Then once we know who and why we can decide what to do about it. However consider what is required to pull this off: 1. Having an airport capable of landing a 777 that nobody knows about 2. Having refuling equipment and fuel. 3. Having a hangar capable of storing the 777 out of the eyes of satellites. These are not small requirements. Whoever did this was quite prepared. It was not pilot suicide based on the data we have. Whoever did this was large, organized, and had tons of resources (we are talking about a large drug ring or a small country here). Against a determined enemy like that I don't know that you really can stop them at the plane. Instead you need real defence in depth, and we can't even talk about that until we know more.
- Perdition 13y ago>Show me a case where an IN-FLIGHT transponder shutdown is a needed issue How would the system determine it is in-flight and thus prevent a maintenance shut down? You would need another device to determine in-flight from ground operations, and thus another device that can malfunction and thus can be defeated by an attacker. >Give me any reasonable response to why this is not something that should be fixed. Give me a reasonable response why spending a bunch of money to fix this rare issue is worth it over other safety improvements? Old aircraft, poor maintenance, and overworked pilots kill many times more people than hijackers. P.S. Why don't we track buses? Why don't we track cars? Why don't we track everybody?
- Perdition 13y agoTransponders are active radio transmitters, there are plenty of situations where they need to be shut down (electrical faults, interference with airport radars, safety of maintenance technicians). A plane being hijacked in this way is so incredible rare that having always-on transponders is not worth the safety trade off.