10 ms·
The Tyranny of Structurelessness (1970)
- pron 13y agoIn case some context is necessary, this excellent article was pointed out to me by scott_s as part of the discussion of the stuff going on at GitHub.
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y agoThanks for posting this article. I've seen it linked several times in recent years; probably even here on HN. However, it's still relevant. Again.
- amirmc 13y agoIt's been posted as an item before but I don't think it hung around long. It's definitely been referred to (and linked) in many threads where the idea of 'no-management' or flat structures crops up. e.g threads on Valve. The irony is that it puts into words what many people have already experienced (in some sense) via high-school. Although it's long, I tend to point people at this story if they're having an anti-management rant with me during a discussion.
- MaxGabriel 13y agoThe blue background and lack of Safari Reader option made this difficult for me to read. The version on the author's own site is much better designed: http://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm http://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm
- solistice 13y agoThe body color is #00FFFF. You could just change it to #FFFFFF with a html editor, and it'll be black on white. <body bgcolor="#00FFFF"> => <body bgcolor="#FFFFFF">
- workhere-io 13y agoThe long line lengths don't help either. Normally you should aim for 12 words per line. http://www.maxdesign.com.au/articles/em/ http://www.maxdesign.com.au/articles/em/
- vanderZwan 13y agoI use this bookmarklet for websites like this (if there is no other version available): http://readable.tastefulwords.com/ http://readable.tastefulwords.com/ Also great for preparing websites for printing too, when that is required.
- wcummings 13y agoMY EYESSSSSS
- Yetanfou 13y agoView->Page Style->No Style (in Firefox) turns it into a rather readable and certainly responsive page. Less is more. Ain't HTML great?
- GroverLipscomb 13y agoCriminy, haven't your so called leftist "elitists" been friends of the feminist movement??
- hosh 13y ago"Contrary to what we would like to believe, there is no such thing as a “structureless” group. Any group of people of whatever nature that comes together for any length of time for any purpose will inevitably structure itself in some fashion. " This assertion is not quite true. When I think of "structure", I am thinking of deliberate, conscious, and rational attempts to create a sort of rigid ... structure. What he is describing is better termed as "dynamic". I make this distinction because I've typically found (as a man), men tends to think and work with structures more often than with the dynamics... the natural ebb and flow of a group without a "structure". When you start thinking about accomplishing a goal (whether a man or a woman) as a group, you start talking about structure, or "process" or any number of those words. That's when you use a particular part of the consciousness to drive and coordinate efforts. So when you start trying to look at what the group can do, accomplish, or its utility, you naturally start looking at structure, and perhaps even imposing structure. Dynamics, or flow will happen regardless of whether we consciously attempt to structure the group or not. When you're not aiming for a particular goal, you can simply just be with the group, to feel and experience the way the group comes together and disperses. There is great wisdom in this, something that has been obscured because it doesn't produce anything that can be easily quantified. I know programmers have talked about "flow" or "zone", about teams that have "gelled". These are all related to the wisdom of being, rather than that of doing. "Flow state", or "zone" is that sweet spot where your effort becomes effortless because you've relaxed into the flow while ... flowing to the goal. Flow states are one of the experiences we can have with consciousness, and you get there by first relaxing and getting more in touch with being ... and dropping some of your fixation on structure. In truth, you see this play between structure and dynamic, between effort and flow. It's just that, most of us are so fixated on the doing and the structure, we are no longer aware of the natural dynamic. This is something I've noticed many (not all) women naturally understand this, and generally, men are pretty clueless about. When men typically encounter this, men will argue about it until we are blue in the face; usually, the women will agree, thus reinforcing this fixation. Women's liberation, in my opinion, is less about liberating women, and more about whacking men with a clue-by-four.
- ayelton 13y ago"What he is describing is better termed as "dynamic"." The author of this essay is a woman.
- jacques_chester 13y agoIt's important to be mindful that the successful examples of flat / bossless organisations often discussed on HN are massively profitable. What's missing from this picture? Statistics and case studies of flat/bossless organisations where money is very tight. There is severe survivor bias at play. Massive profitability allows you to get away with just about anything. People think that the market rewards virtue or merit; that profit is the reward for this or that method, strategy or culture. Not really. Market systems are agnostic to how a company is run. If you stumble on a gold mine, the market doesn't reward you because you flog your miners. It likewise doesn't reward you because you pamper your miners. It rewards you for having gold. For every Valve and Github, there is a Microsoft or an Oracle.
- edanm 13y agoExactly right. Even Google, while not being a flat/bossless organisation, is an example of a company with a product that makes such gobsmacking amounts of money, that they have plenty of spare to throw at amazing luxury for their people, at "20%" time, etc. Having a product that brings you so much money lets you spend enormous amounts on trying (and sometimes failing) at new things, whether it be R&D, new organisation types, etc. But it's important to remember that the vast, vast majority of companies are not in this situation, and, while profitable, are not so massively profitable that they can afford such things.
- jjoonathan 13y agoIs 20% time still a thing or did it die with Google Labs?
- DanielBMarkham 13y agoGreat comment. Executives are machine-builders. Some areas of tech are starting to look like rock-band territory: great idea, cool team, right buzz, catch the wave at the right time, execution intelligence -> profit. How you execute? Not so much. When the market settles, and you're doing something everybody else is doing that has an established value proposition and distribution channel? The game changes. Or even when you're the 10th successful entrant into a field the game changes. Then you're looking at building the most efficient machine you can. Companies make a ton of mistakes trying to continue to eliminate inefficiencies from organizational structure, but that doesn't mean there's none to be found. I fear that survivor bias is teaching the wrong lesson to an entire generation of business leaders. But hell, should make for some great case studies over the next 10-20 years if nothing else.
- kabdib 13y agoThe moment you have two primates and a banana, you're going to get politics.
- stcredzero 13y agoIf the two primates are bonobos, the usual result is sex.
- Pxtl 13y agoWhich is still politics.
- stcredzero 13y agoIndeed. Didn't one noble in the 30 years war switch sides at what amounts to the prompting of his girlfriend?
- amirmc 13y agoAnd the form of that politics will vary. c.f. Two wolves and a sheep deciding on what to have for dinner.
- lukifer 13y agoI love this analogy, but the funny thing is that it works both ways: whatever a wolf and two sheep might vote on for dinner, it's not gonna be sheep (or even wolf). Hence, it is the wolves and not the sheep who usually have the greater resentment for democracy.
- cpeterso 13y agoPolitics requires at least three people. With only two people, there is no us-vs-them.
- wpietri 13y agoFor those who would like to know more about this, I can't recommend De Waal's Chimpanzee Politics enough. I read this as a young nerd and suddenly people made a lot more sense to me. First things about society (especially companies). Then things about individual people. And, most recently, things about myself.
- dpweb 13y agoFlat/no-bosses, untrue. Clash between the founder and employee, who's out the door?
- Eliezer 13y agoAm I over-inferring from one piece of info, or does this writing represent an entire branch of early feminism which lost the struggle for the heart of the movement and was driven out by worse ideas?
- ngpio 13y agoI suspect you're over-inferring, and it's hard to tell what you mean by "heart" and "worse". Reading the oft-cited anarchist response might provide some context (though it was written in 2005): http://libcom.org/library/tyranny-of-tyranny-cathy-levine http://libcom.org/library/tyranny-of-tyranny-cathy-levine Nearly every time the Tyranny of Structurelessness is posted to some activist's facebook wall these days, a link to the Tyranny of Tyranny is in the first few comments. Then the discussion devolves into rehashed bickering, though never about the actual content of the pieces.
- igravious 13y agoThis (Tyranny of Structurelessness) pamphlet was one of many diverse pamphlets on a board in an anarcho-communist activist/literature space where I used to volunteer. I'm more than surprised to see it posted here and it pleases me to see that there is a critique (Tyranny of tyranny). Has there ever been a pole about the political leanings of HN or would it be impossible to enumerate the categories? [] anarchist [] socialist [] republican [] monarchist [] libertarian [] free market capitalist taxes are theft ayn rand is my god [] conservative [] democrat [] i really couldn't tell you old boy
- ngpio 13y agoI'd be more interested in a heat map of Political Compass[1] results or something similar. It's not a great model, but it's slightly less terrible than a bunch of pre-globalization labels. And ultimately, I've stopped caring about how people define themselves politically. No matter how deep into activist milieus I got[2], my politics were always consequentialist. And to actually be a consequentialist you have to shut the hell up, strategize, build and iterate. Introspective and social identities are no exception to that. [1] http://politicalcompass.org/analysis2 http://politicalcompass.org/analysis2 [2] Note the strict past tense.
- patmcguire 13y agoIf anyone's having trouble reading... https://www.readability.com/articles/vot5qmk3 https://www.readability.com/articles/vot5qmk3
- jamesbritt 13y agoThat just redirects me to the original site. The "zap colors" bookmarklet is helpful here: https://www.squarefree.com/bookmarklets/zap.html https://www.squarefree.com/bookmarklets/zap.html
- stcredzero 13y agoContrary to what we would like to believe, there is no such thing as a “structureless” group. Even anonymous developed small groups within vying for power as inner cabals. Also structureless groups are still subject to evaporative cooling, if not more so. This has profound implications for things like open source projects, language communities, and startup communities.
- jes5199 13y agowhat do you mean by "evaporative cooling"?
- jfarmer 13y agoThe most high-value people in a group are the first to leave as the group grows and the average value of the group decreases, accelerating the decline of the average value of the group. To prevent this you need structures in place to retain value for the highest-value people, e.g., strict policing on who gets to join the group or the ability to form groups-within-groups.
- shalmanese 13y agohttp://blog.bumblebeelabs.com/social-software-sundays-2-the-evaporative-cooling-effect/ http://blog.bumblebeelabs.com/social-software-sundays-2-the-...
- patmcguire 13y agoI always want to paste the same excerpt from War and Peace when this comes up: "When Boris entered the room, Prince Andrey was listening to an old general, wearing his decorations, who was reporting something to Prince Andrey, with an expression of soldierly servility on his purple face. “Alright. Please wait!” he said to the general, speaking in Russian with the French accent which he used when he spoke with contempt. The moment he noticed Boris he stopped listening to the general who trotted imploringly after him and begged to be heard, while Prince Andrey turned to Boris with a cheerful smile and a nod of the head. Boris now clearly understood—what he had already guessed—that side by side with the system of discipline and subordination which were laid down in the Army Regulations, there existed a different and more real system—the system which compelled a tightly laced general with a purple face to wait respectfully for his turn while a mere captain like Prince Andrey chatted with a mere second lieutenant like Boris. Boris decided at once that he would be guided not by the official system but by this other unwritten system."
- amirmc 13y agoI haven't read War and Peace, so I don't know the context of this excerpt. Despite that, I'd like to suggest that if you have a formal structure in an organisation, then you're still able to use it to do something about the informal structures that you don't like (assuming you can recognise them). If you've explicitly eschewed any kind of formal structure, then changing it becomes very difficult [1]. In this example, Boris could have decided that he would try and support the formal structures and wrest control (over time) from the informal leaders (perhaps by playing both sides for a while). [1] Edit: The reverse is also true. You can adapt a formal structure by the use of informal power. This is more often talked about (c.f. every 'influence' book ever written), so I didn't think to mention it.
- jacques_chester 13y agoI think the thing is that the formal and informal structures need to be somewhat in alignment. A lot of countries have the form of institutions, but not the deep-rooted culture. In theory the British Parliament could collectively lose its marbles and transform the UK into a totalitarian state in the space of a few weeks. In practice it's very unlikely to happen. The informal and formal are closely aligned in the political culture. In theory Russia has the separation of powers and independent media. In practice, it doesn't. The informal and formal are misaligned, which in some ways is worse than never having the formal stuff in the first place.
- 7402 13y agoOriginal source (on the author's web site) is here: http://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm http://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm
- awongh 13y agoThis was an excellent read. I feel like it's coming from the trenches from someone who's had much experience creating structureless groups.... tldr: the conclusion/action points are: Principles of Democratic Structuring 1) Delegation of specific authority to specific individuals for specific tasks by democratic procedures. 2) Requiring all those to whom authority has been delegated to be responsible to those who selected them. 3) Distribution of authority among as many people as is reasonably possible. 4) Rotation of tasks among individuals. 5) Allocation of tasks along rational criteria. 6) Diffusion of information to everyone as frequently as possible. 7) Equal access to resources needed by the group.
- jrochkind1 13y agoThanks for this comment. I think too often this essay is interpreted as an argument for hierarchical control, when that is not what it seems to me to be arguing for, or how it would have been interpreted in the context it was written -- where a commitment to egalitarian and democratic organization was a baseline assumption. The thing is, egalitarian organization is hard, and the contribution of this valuable essay is to point put that simply abolishing structure does't get you there -- and to specifically point out how it can still lead to hierarchy and authoritarianism. But that hierarchy and authoritarianism are still identified as the problem --requiring solutions other than structurelessness-- not the solution to some other problem! which leaves me curious what is being suggested as the applicability to github. I wonder if those at github actually see it as an org committed to democracy or egalitarianism. to me, despite an unusually flat org chart, its still a company with certain people in charge and certain equity owners, dedicated to efficiency and profit for it's owners.
- pron 13y agoThe problem isn't hierarchy or authoritarianism (though the latter is a symptom of it), but the distribution of power in any organization (or society), regardless of its goals. The point is simple: shying away from a clear power structure results only in an unfair and unmanageable distribution of power. Companies like GitHub, that believe in "self-organizations" would often fall into this trap once they grow large enough. Julie Ann Horvath's story at GitHub demonstrates how events unfold when the power structure isn't explicit.
- michaelochurch 13y agoStructurelessness is a bad idea. It's taking some good concepts (open allocation, self-direction) too far. It means that management is lazy and absent rather than aware, principled, and effective. Open allocation still requires management to keep it open. Closed allocation is worse and basically terrible, because there's an inherent conflict of interest between people and project management. Advocating for 10 people, and having to make those 10 people deliver on a specific executive mandate, has a person serving two masters. It might be that the best thing for a person is to change projects, but that conflicts with the manager's need to manage up and won't happen. You still need people who can protect the good (sheepdogs). Always. I don't care how flat an organization is, there has got to be someone who, if harassment occurs or someone is impeding others' work, says "Not fucking acceptable". The problem is that it's really hard to give someone that power and not have it be abused.
- anachrokate 13y agoThis was written by a state communist, so you can imagine what "structure" she advocated, and the anarchists immediately replied with The Tyranny of Tyranny http://www.libcom.org/library/tyranny-of-tyranny-cathy-levine http://www.libcom.org/library/tyranny-of-tyranny-cathy-levin...
- pron 13y agoExcept history, in Silicon Valley (http://blogs.hbr.org/2014/01/how-silicon-valley-became-the-man/ http://blogs.hbr.org/2014/01/how-silicon-valley-became-the-m...) as elsewhere, is unequivocally on Jo Freeman's side. No actual revolution (as opposed to imagined ones) ever managed to remain structureless, and those that aspired to be the most structureless quickly became as oppressive as the most tyrannical ones.
- jahaja 13y agoFor additional context; what/which revolution(s) are you thinking about that aspired to be the most structureless but became as oppressive as the most tyrannical ones?
- pron 13y agoPretty much all the communist ones; the French; counterculture (see the linked article as well as Adam Curtis's documentaries)
- watwut 13y agoCommunists never aspired to be structureless, definitely not in the short term. Even utopia they promised in long term had element of forced conformity with system aka oppression. Path towards that utopia was supposed to go through strong party discipline and obeisance. That is how communist party survived oppression in Russia. It was not supposed to be "free" or "structureless" in any current meaning of the word. I now much less about French revolution, but what I know suggests it was very complicated event. Describing it as simple attempt to move towards structureless society is simplifying it too much.
- anon4 13y agoAnd this is why I prefer 4chan to reddit. By eliminating individual identities (except on a few niche boards, almost nobody posts in any identifiable way) from a group, you are left with no way to form personal cliques. You can identify people by their actions, sure. Like "that person who draws those video-games comics" or "that person who knows a lot about kernel development and posts help in the programming threads" (this is a hypothetical person, I haven't met one like that on 4chan yet) &c. But you don't have a name on those usually and even if they do use one, those people only use it to post that content, rather than in general. You don't know if the person is male, female, or a raptor butterfly from Venus. The threads are also flat and you cannot upvote posts. This prevents the upvote-echo-chamber effect you can see on reddit. If you wish to drown out another opinion, you have to actually post more than the other anon, you can't just call your friends on IRC and have them upvote via puppet accounts or whatnot. And there is an enforced minimum time between posts, which is greatly increased if you attempt to post the same thing twice in a row. Every dissenting opinion is given equal opportunity for being heard (as long as it's not about posting gore pics out of sheer asshattery - that shit gets you banned). This does sound very unstructured and some kinds of groups do arise, but they're centered around shared interests and not identities. It's kind of strange putting it like that, but 4chan is probably one of the sites on the internet where it's hardest to hurt a specific person. You can post hurtful remarks about some other person's post or opinions, but without an identity to attach to that person, you can't go on to hurt them in other threads. Or even in the same thread in many cases. Now, there are people on certain boards that voice general opinions that will hurt you and make you angry. I suggest posting right back at them. 4chan's design won't work in all cases, though. For instance, StackOverflow and friends work perfectly with the reddit model. But the point of SO is to get the best possible answer to a question. The point of 4chan is to enable fair discussion (also pictures of cats and porn, as long as it's not porn with cats). It's a shame 4chan is the only well-known site on the internet using that model. I'd love to see different platforms experiment with fully anonymous posting and no upvote system. P.S. I'm not moot
- k__ 13y ago> The threads are also flat and you cannot upvote posts. THIS. You have to conduct REAL interaction with the "thread". Not just artificially by voting for stuff you like. Information is everything that matters. The only upvote-like mechanism is posting in a thread. There are still people posting stuff without additional informations to show their approval, but they have to type something and type a captcha, which prevents the whole mass from skimming over boards and randomly vote as they go.
- yarrel 13y agoIt's so much easier to capture an organization when you can simply buy it.
- pradocchia 13y agoRight, so if the women's liberation movement hadn't made flat orgs so fashionable, then maybe Github would still be a nice place for all kinds to work, and we wouldn't have this whole class of pseudo-sexist problems. Am I reading this right?
- azernik 13y agoWow. The section "Political Impotence" describes the experience of working in a well-functioning "structureless organization", and it sounds a lot like the descriptions of early-stage startups. (Chunks omitted with ellipses for brevity; go check out the whole thing!) "While working in this kind of group is a very heady experience, it is also rare and very hard to replicate. There are almost inevitably four conditions found in such a group: 1. It is task oriented. Its function is very narrow and very specific, like putting on a conference or putting out a newspaper. It is the task that basically structures the group... 2. It is relatively small and homogeneous. Homogeneity is necessary to ensure that participants have a “common language” or interaction. ...too great a diversity among members of a task-oriented group means only that they continually misunderstand each other... If everyone knows everyone else well enough to understand the nuances, these can be accommodated. Usually, they only lead to confusion and endless hours spent straightening out conflicts no one ever thought would arise. 3. There is a high degree of communication... This is only possible if the group is small and people practically live together for the most crucial phases of the task....Successful groups can be as large as 10 or 15, but only when they are in fact composed of several smaller subgroups which perform specific parts of the task, and whose members overlap with each other so that knowledge of what the different subgroups are doing can be passed around easily. 4. There is a low degree of skill specialization. Not everyone has to be able to do everything, but everything must be able to be done by more than one person..."
- nnq 13y agoIsn't it incredibly obvious that hierarchical structures, even when they start o get a hint of tyranny, offer more freedom to the individual than "structureless" ones?! (my definition of "freedom" here is "freedom to do my thing however I want to do it, whether the majority agree or nor, whether I'm right or not"). In a "structureless"/"not explicitly structured" social system you have to always keep your senses sharp and always be observant about the hidden power structure that always changes. This takes a huuuge amount of mental energy, at least for me, and I can put this energy to waaaay better uses. In a functional "structured system", even if for short periods of time the wrong people get in charge, you can at least not spend 50% of your energy in tasks related to the perpetual reorganization of the power structure and the silent but continuous fights for power, and actually have time and energy for solving the problems (and no, the problem is never "who's in charge?", nobody gives a fuck "who's in charge"!) Yeah, you may have to do the problem solving while lying "yes sir, I'll do it like this" to the bosses, and then go on and do things "your way" in reality, but it's waaaaay less stressful then either: - being in/around a perpetual silent power-fight - not knowing who really is in charge (this is what I find the most stressful, because if you know who really is in charge you can solve any serious problem by jumping over your superiors and talking to someone more enlightened higher up the food chain) "Non-micromanaging 'cold' hierarchies" (by 'cold' I mean both "relatively rigid", like not in a continuous reorganization and power fight, and non-empathic to even semi-autistical, like being relatively unperturbed by temporary emotions) and "benevolent tyrants" are to me the best models for helping the "makers" function at 100%. And "the makers" are the ones actually solving the problems and keeping the profit flow.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]