4 ms·
But don't we celebrate the idea of equality (in certain contexts at least), meritocracy, democracy, etc... and strive for them as ideals?
by davidw 13y ago
But don't we celebrate the idea of equality (in certain contexts at least), meritocracy, democracy, etc... and strive for them as ideals?
- steveklabnik 13y agoWomen not being harassed at the workplace is an entirely possible goal. Meritocracy is impossible. The very first question that comes into play is "who defines and measures merit?" Consider another failed opportunity at 'meritocracy': eugenics. It was once believed that we could determine some kind of 'genetic quality' and, well, have a meritocracy in human breeding, in a way. Turns out that whole idea is totally broken. At one point in time, people thought IQ was a reasonable way to measure merit. Turns out that it's not. "Women (and others) do not feel unsafe in their work environment" is reasonably quantifiable, and someday, achievable. 'Merit' is not.
- davidw 13y ago> "Women (and others) do not feel unsafe in their work environment" is reasonably quantifiable, and someday, achievable. 'Merit' is not. Agreed, but... isn't the 'trying' that counts in terms of the latter? I just don't see the problem in holding up "meritocracy" as something to strive for. I don't think any of us lives in a perfect democracy either, but we are still proud of trying, and think that it's the best way to run things, even if we're painfully aware of the shortcomings.
- steveklabnik 13y ago> I just don't see the problem in holding up "meritocracy" as something to strive for. Please read the article I linked in my first comment, which directly explains this. Or this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7406566 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7406566
- davidw 13y agoI think we're going to have to agree to disagree. The idea that a company (we're not talking politics) hires people based only on them being the best at what they do strikes me as sensible, and, no, not the 'status quo'. Here in Italy it's still "who you know" that counts in many cases, so the idea of trying to be more merit-based strikes me as positive, even if, no, no one should think they're 100% there. I think it's also distracting from the issue at hand, which I think is very real and important.