5 ms·
I just don't take these people seriously anymore. It seems like a uniquely north american woman phenomenon. Why is that I almost never hear about a German fema
by sergiotapia 13y ago
I just don't take these people seriously anymore. It seems like a uniquely north american woman phenomenon.
Why is that I almost never hear about a German female software developer crying wolf?
This person could have been legitimately harassed, but all of the bullshit flooding online has made me grow a thick skin and just not care anymore because I think it's fake.
- badman_ting 13y ago> Why is that I almost never hear about a German female software developer crying wolf? Indeed, why.
- rmc 13y agoThere is a lot of sexism in Europe. e.g. the European Union tried to get more women into science with a campaign called "Science: It's a girl thing"[1]. The promotional video[2] is painfully archiac. It looks like something straight out of Mad Men. "Pete, women are only interested in make up, so make sure we have lots of that" [1] https://science-girl-thing.eu/en/splash https://science-girl-thing.eu/en/splash [2] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g032MPrSjFA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g032MPrSjFA
- sergiotapia 13y agoThat video is just cringe-worthy. What were they thinking?!
- facepalm 13y agoPerhaps they were thinking of TV Shows like Germany's Next Top Model? While I also think the video is ridiculous, who knows, perhaps it actually works for the audience of that TV show (which is most teenage girls). Advertising is more interested in results than in political correctness. Then again, advertising paid for by tax money? I suspect somebody went golfing and sealed the deal...
- RyanZAG 13y agoIt's cringe-worthy for you, but it's actually popular amongst the target demographic and has probably done more for getting girls into tech than most other initiatives. You can deny it all you want, but many girls really do like that kind of thing - and denying their right to like that stuff is just as bad as denying their right to join the tech workforce. EDIT: I mean the initiative as a whole, not the video alone. The whole initiative has been done in a fairly cringe worthy way for me though, but for the target audience it mostly gets it right.
- rmc 13y agoThe video itself was taken down very quickly after numerous actual women in science saw it and (publically) WTFed.
- rmc 13y agoMaybe it was a whole pile of men who had no idea how women think?
- petercooper 13y agoWhat about this sort of thing though? Seems to be extremely popular amongst the target audience. http://www.amazon.com/Girls-Get-Curves-Geometry-Takes/dp/0452298741/ http://www.amazon.com/Girls-Get-Curves-Geometry-Takes/dp/045... http://www.amazon.com/Hot-Algebra-Exposed-Danica-McKellar/dp/0452297192/ http://www.amazon.com/Hot-Algebra-Exposed-Danica-McKellar/dp...
- facepalm 13y agoAre you sure the target audience is women? :-)
- rmc 13y agoIt's either (a) evidence of that being extremely popular with women (b) or evidence of people with the power/ability/money/resources to make/sell/publish books thinking that that sort of thing is extremely popular with women. Not the same thing at all. After all, the original video was made by the European Commission to publicise their women in science campaign, which does not mean that the video is popular with women in science. Sometimes organisations make mistakes or are wrong.
- mwfunk 13y agoThe irony here is palpable. Wow.
- boredandroid 13y agoLet me give several alternate reasons: 1. There are far fewer Germans. 2. The percentage of software engineers in Germany is lower. 3. Germany has fewer startups. Large companies typically take gender equality pretty seriously, if for no other reason than that they are more risk averse. 4. Germans have the annoying tendency to speak and write in German. So while there may be quite a lot of people discussing problems in Germany far fewer people can read these and none are posted to english language websites like hacker news. So assuming the problem was equally prevalent at software startups in both countries would expect to hear about it a lot less from Germany.
- crucialfelix 13y agoAlso it tends to be very much under reported because it's seen as often quite normal in Germany. I live in Germany and have female friends who worked in tech here.
- Jgrubb 13y agoIf you have a thick skin, then you won't mind my telling you that this is not the first time I've read a rude, immature comment on here and then looked above it to see your name attached to it.
- sergiotapia 13y agoThat's your opinion I guess, should I blog about it on my tumblr account?
- MartinCron 13y agoOr even better, keep it to yourself?
- klaut 13y agoi did not find the comment rude, nor immature. In fact, i tend to agree with it.
- intortus 13y agoReally? It sounded pretty gross to me: "I just don't take these people seriously anymore. It seems like a uniquely north american woman phenomenon."
- tzs 13y agoAll of the incidents of claimed harassment in tech that have resulted in enough noise that I have noticed them (5, if I am remembering correctly) have involved North American women. I think they were all in the United States, in fact. There could be some bias because I'm in the United States, and most of the tech news and tech discussion sites I read are in the US, so I'm probably more likely to learn of things happening in the US than in the rest of the world. Still, given that every example I can think of is North American, I cannot criticize his observation.
- intortus 13y ago
- davidw 13y agoMatteo Renzi brought on a pregnant woman as a minister in his new government here in Italy, and I've read and heard no end of comments about it. Like she has some kind of disease that prevents her from working. So, yes, sexist bullshit exists the world over. Generally though, these things don't get resolved in threads like this, or even through laws or prominent lawsuits (although they can help). My feeling is that things really improve a bit at a time when each and every one of us becomes more vigilant about what goes on around us, and acts - perhaps just in a small way - to try and improve the situation whenever we see stuff that's not right. The other thing about acting locally is you act on stuff that you see and hear yourself, so none of this "he said, she said" stuff.
- facepalm 13y agoPregnancy is not a disease, but it does prevent you from working at least part of the time. Just saying - I don't know anything about that Italian story.
- davidw 13y agoOnce the child is born, it can prevent you from working. That much is true, although there are ways to deal with that too given some money and drive (see: Marissa Mayer). But if you're an ordinary office worker, and aren't doing heavy labor, no, pregnancy is not generally an obstacle to doing work. My wife worked in a laboratory on her feet most of the time pretty much up until the end. She went for a 10 km walk a few days before our daughter was born.
- facepalm 13y agoOk then lets say there is a probability >> 0 of not being able to work all the time. Several acquaintances had to lie in bed for weeks. My wife is also currently having issues. If P(can't work) > 0 it means E(days can't work) is also > 0. Also stress for the mother is supposedly bad for the baby. Not sure how stress free a job as minister of the state can be expected to be.
- claudius 13y ago
- untog 13y agoWhy is that I almost never hear about a German female software developer crying wolf? Did it not occur to you that it might be because German female software developers are treated better and it's North American tech culture that causes the problem? But yeah probably a bunch of whiny girls amirite lol
- sergiotapia 13y agoHonestly, if Ms. Julie was _actually_ harassed I hope that she gets proper retribution in whatever form works best for her. It's just that I seen so many 'false-positives' before that just made me roll my eyes and think, "that's not really sexism.". She is accusing people and a very large company of SERIOUS things, I hope she actually has proof her lawyer can use. I want her to have a happy ending.
- silencio 13y ago> "that's not really sexism" The thing is, sexism and sexual harassment boils down to a lot of he-said-she-said, people individually passing judgment on what happened, and one person's definition of sexism isn't another person's definition while whatever happened has happened. Just because some people have a way thicker skin doesn't mean that even the smallest things should be given a free pass, and in a lot of these situations it's nearly impossible to get any proof of anything happening. Like I hate that it's only March this year and I've had two men in 4? tech events with men attending just sit down next to me without asking if they could do so and try to talk to me - while I was coding on my laptop sitting by myself in the corner of the room on purpose while everyone else was further away chatting next to the food. Like if that's not a cue to leave me alone, I don't know what is. A shirt that says "fuck off" or telling them I'm busy like they'll even acknowledge that unless I just get up and leave - but then why do I have to do that? And of course, this wouldn't be complete without people telling me that that experience was just normal so be quiet and I shouldn't be surprised to encounter people with terrible social skills in tech. Thanks? Like, I should stop feeling uncomfortable when strangers sit close enough for our thighs to touch because at least they're not groping my breasts or raping me on video so that meets your standard for proof? And my terrible social skills can't be that terrible because I know when to leave strangers alone? The best reply - and by best I really mean the stupidest one - is when my friends and acquaintances take my complaints seriously and offer to go with me in the future or do something about a guy annoying me or help me with whatever I'm currently doing for other women in tech, but then they complain that Shanley or some other "feminazi" is whining on Twitter again why can't that bitch shut up. Like what the hell. I just don't like to complain about things but I have a MOUNTAIN of stories to tell you if you were interested. And complaining and making things public doesn't make my message any less valid. Even if it's something trivial, even if it's after all that Julie has said against other feminists, even if there's no proof that anything serious happened but something happened... if it made her uncomfortable, there's a problem there that needs to be fixed.
- ezy 13y ago> It seems like a uniquely north american woman phenomenon. False. [1][2][3][4][5][6][...] [1] http://www.forbes.com/sites/deannazandt/2013/02/01/germanys-problem-with-women/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/deannazandt/2013/02/01/germanys-... [2] http://www.dw.de/opinion-how-sexist-is-germany/a-16555500 http://www.dw.de/opinion-how-sexist-is-germany/a-16555500 [3] http://interculturalmusings.blogspot.com/2013/07/germanys-biggest-problem-sexism.html http://interculturalmusings.blogspot.com/2013/07/germanys-bi... [4] http://www.economist.com/news/europe/21571188-where-does-germany-stand-sexism-cloud-over-rainer http://www.economist.com/news/europe/21571188-where-does-ger... [5] http://freespeechdebate.com/fr/2013/06/twitter-free-speech-and-sexism-an-outcry-from-germany/ http://freespeechdebate.com/fr/2013/06/twitter-free-speech-a... [6] http://www.cafebabel.co.uk/society/article/sexism-on-europes-streets-the-unbearable-heaviness-of-being.html http://www.cafebabel.co.uk/society/article/sexism-on-europes... [...] Google: "sexism germany". It would have taken you two seconds to do this before spouting off, but that would've required humility...
- crucialfelix 13y agoAnecdotal, but I have a friend who worked at eBay 'schland and at a ring tone company in Berlin. She was stunned at how everybody treated her like a toy, like a girl to be played with. One of her bosses told her outright that he would just steal her ideas, take credit for it and never give her a raise or credit. After years here she finally moved back to the US. She now does iOS and rails development in SF/Oakland. Another friend of mine is German, female and doing well in iOS dev in Berlin now. Anecdotal. So it's not 100% bad and German tech environment is improving overall I would say.
- qohen 13y agoI just don't take these people seriously anymore. It seems like a uniquely north american woman phenomenon This reminds me how many in the Catholic Church had exactly the same attitude of denial about clerical pedophilia -- that it was an American phenomenon -- but they soon learned better (and, by coincidence, this article[1] on the topic is specifically about Germany): BERLIN - The German Catholic church, which long regarded pedophilia among the clergy as a particularly American phenomenon, is now bracing for a possible crisis of credibility among the country's more than 27 million Catholics. In recent weeks, half a dozen dioceses have come under intense media scrutiny for past abuse by priests and attempts by the church hierarchy to hush up the scandals. Critics are calling the revelations only the tip of the iceberg, while the church scrambles to control the damage. [1]http://www.boston.com/globe/spotlight/abuse/print2/080402_germany.htm http://www.boston.com/globe/spotlight/abuse/print2/080402_ge...