3 ms·
It's very arguable that every decisionmaking process must come down to a number, as we're talking about people and not cattle. It's not debatable if you believ
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
It's very arguable that every decisionmaking process must come down to a number, as we're talking about people and not cattle.
It's not debatable if you believe in the axiom of induction (or the axiom of choice for countably infinite sets).
Theorem: If there is a total order (a consistent decisionmaking process) on the set of people (or any countable set), then there exists an order preserving function f: People->Real numbers.
Sketch of proof: Start with an arbitrary person A. Define the ranking function f(A)=0. Choose an arbitrary person besides A, call them B. If B > A then f(B)=1, else if B = a then f(B)=0 else f(B) = -1. Choose a third person C, different from A and B. If C > max(A,B) define F(C) = f(max(A,B))+1. If A < C < B or B < C < A define f(C)=0.5x(f(A)+f(B)). If C < min(A,B) then f(C) = f(min(A,B))-1. Continue ad nauseum.
Either it's false that multiple intelligences exist, or it's useless to single-dimensinally evaluate them.
Multiple intelligences probably don't exist. But even supposing they do, claiming that the domain of a function is multidimensional does not disagree with my claim that the range is one dimensional.
Background:
A total order is a way of saying "person A is at least as good as person B" which obeys all the obvious laws. Person B can be either a real person or a standard of achievement (e.g. "passing").
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_order http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Total_order
http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2013/metrics_manifesto.html http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2013/metrics_manifesto.htm...
- xamuel 13y agoHoly circular reasoning, Batman! The premise of your theorem, that there is such a total order, is equivalent to the existence of such a numbering function. You're saying "A must be true because B is true", where B is just an identical version of A, disingenuously obfuscated by a thin veneer of mathematics! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fashionable_Nonsense http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fashionable_Nonsense This all ignoring the fact any such "total order" is going to be highly variable through time (today's top engineer is tomorrow's dementia patient is yesterday's toddler)!
- yummyfajitas 13y agoA total order is a consistent objective decisionmaking function. I'm assuming that consistency and objectivity are obvious properties that any reasonable process must have. If you want to argue against consistency and/or objectivity, go ahead and do so. It'll certainly be interesting.
- pliny 13y agoThe theorem is fine, but there's obviously not a total order of 'general aptitude' on the set of people since there definitely exist two people and two jobs for which the first person is better at the first job than the second person and worse at the second job than the second person.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoEach job would have a different decision function. Of course, it's irrelevant for exams - the decision function in that case is just to answer the question "is student A > minimum passing standard" or "is student A > student B at math".