5 ms·
I'm immediately extraordinarily skeptical about anything that suggests solving a cultural problem by changing language. That's like trying to solve a math prob
by wyager 13y ago
I'm immediately extraordinarily skeptical about anything that suggests solving a cultural problem by changing language.
That's like trying to solve a math problem by changing the value of pi.
- thaumasiotes 13y agoAgreed, but imagine how many more math problems you could solve if you were allowed to do that :D
- Thirdegree 13y agoThe answer to every geometry question I run into is now 7.
- corin_ 13y agoThere is at least a theoretical logic to banning words like this: if being called bossy is causing girls to lose leadership skills then maybe stopping this artificially (even if people still think it without saying it) could lead to less girls being affected, and therefore in the next generation the stigma has disappeared. Obviously it's not that simple, and I have no idea to what extent, if any, this actually works, other than in theory.
- Crito 13y ago> "if being called bossy is causing girls to lose leadership skills..." I don't think that this particular word is the root cause. More important is the reason why people are using it. If you ban that particular word without addressing why people are using it, then those people will adopt a new word to mean the exact same thing. Creating euphemism treadmills doesn't fix anything.
- jkestner 13y agoYep. Some people are taking this too literally. (Nerds parsing? No!) The heightened awareness of how word choice subtly undermines behavior we presumably want to encourage, is the point. This article suggests that instead of banning, women embrace the word as a badge they're doing something right (a la 'nerd'), and undermining the undermining would work too.
- jk4930 13y ago"if being called bossy is causing girls to lose leadership skills" ... then they aren't leaders anyway.
- judk 13y agoThis is exactly the problem: Leadership roles going to those who fight hardest, not those who motivate and inspire.
- gametheoretic 13y agoIf the history of Preferred Medical Term(s) for Mentally/Physically-Challenged Individuals is any indicator, that theory is lame.
- Steko 13y agoWhen culture changes shouldn't language that reflects outdated culture also change? Racial slurs aren't acceptable anymore. No one thinks that change is what brought about the civil rights movement, but it's obviously a consequence of it that also contributed to the whole movement in a positive feedback loop.
- chrismonsanto 13y ago> Racial slurs aren't acceptable anymore. That isn't what brought about the civil rights movement, but it's an important consequence of it. I don't really want to pick sides on 'ban bossy', but I do think this particular analogy is flawed. Unlike a racial slur (or any other identity-based slur), 'bossy' describes intrinsically negative behavior. People who are 'overly authoritative' or 'domineering' will always be looked down on in society whether or not this word is 'banned' or not.
- tesseractive 13y agoYou are starting from the assumption that this movement is in error rather than arguing it to be. The whole point of their argument is that the word "bossy" is used to police women's behavior in situations where the same behavior is considered positive for men -- so simply asserting that it always describes negative behavior doesn't exactly make a useful point. Their claim may in fact be false. But starting from the assumption that it is false doesn't really add anything to the discussion.
- stefantalpalaru 13y ago> Racial slurs aren't acceptable anymore. They are, but their usage is limited to linguistic segregation. Nothing better to keep people in check than enforcing a correlation between the words they are allowed to use and the color of their skin.
- hackinthebochs 13y agoHN, more than most, is a global forum, and with that in mind people should really stop and think before offering their opinion on a subject where critical cultural context is almost surely missing from one's perspective.
- ben0x539 13y agoI think a better comparison would be changing an aspect of the mathematical notation you're using to work on the problem space because it's impeding progress for whatever reason.
- vacri 13y agoThis simile is utter nonsense from the outset. Pi doesn't change. It's the same regardless of who you are, whether you're a human, a dragonfly, or a rock; it's the same whether you're measuring in planck lengths or astromical units. Language is the utter opposite - it constantly evolves and changes, with new words entering every year and grammatical patterns changing over time as well. The only way to stop a language changing is basically to stop using it.
- girvo 13y agoChanging the value of Pi specifically to solve the Square the Circle problem actually nearly happened, which would be he context of grandparents post, I'd wager.
- morganherlocker 13y agoSource, for those interested[1]. The bill was proposed in 1897 in the Indiana state legislature. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indiana_Pi_Bill http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indiana_Pi_Bill
- Torgo 13y agoUse e instead of pi: http://tauday.com/tau-manifesto http://tauday.com/tau-manifesto
- krrishd 13y agoSame here. Our school has a club called "Spread the Word to End the Word" which aims to remove 'derogatory' language from our diction. Removing words isn't going to help, removing prejudice and bigotry in itself is.