4 ms·
While I was a fan of the previous campaign (the day we fight back), this one seems DOA. First, there is no actual action to be taken. There is a date, but to ge
by IgorPartola 13y ago
While I was a fan of the previous campaign (the day we fight back), this one seems DOA. First, there is no actual action to be taken. There is a date, but to get to what the campaign is trying to do you have to watch a two minute video at the end of which it boils down to two calls to action:
1. Developers should add "NSA-resistant features" to their products. No mention of what this actually means.
2. Users should try apps that support their privacy and spread the word about them. No mention of what the apps actually are.
The site itself, as others said, tracks users through Google Analytics. That's right, the same Google that is sending every bit of user data it gets directly to the NSA. You are encouraging us to disable logging in our applications... I don't know what to say to this.
Now, for some more constructive suggestions:
1. Instead of "trying apps", why not focus a bit more on some specific things. For example "try Tor". Most users don't know what that is, but it's a tangible actionable thing someone can spend 30 minutes on and learn something actually valuable.
2. Or, try GPG. This is harder, but I believe can still be something that power users can grasp.
3. For developers, why not hack on Firefox or Chromium to add a Tor-enable private mode. Encourage and fund this project, so that most people can press a button and get a Tor-enabled browser immediately.
4. Or, get developers to set up more Tor nodes and bridges.
5. Or, get developers to finally bring IPv6 to Tor.
6. Or, get developers to create alternatives to specific popular services that are currently monitored by the NSA. The reason GMail is so popular is because it's got a fantastic UI. No open source webmail client comes close. Get developers to volunteer time to develop an alternative that users can host themselves.
- ChrisAntaki 13y agoWe purposefully kept the video vague, so that developers could choose what they felt were the most appropriate improvements, to the vast array of applications out there. Thanks for your ideas. OTR is another good thing to add, for chat applications. Also, good point regarding user interface. As was discussed at SXSW, friendly UI's have a huge affect on the popularity of an application.
- IgorPartola 13y agoGlad you are reading this. One more thing: if you could add a text transcript of the main points of the video that'd be awesome. If I was on my phone I definitely wouldn't have watched the video.
- ChrisAntaki 13y agoThanks, we'll try and integrate that into the website.